MTM Critical Metals (ASX: MTM) down 24%. Ah, yes, we were right to be worried then

MTM Critical Metals (ASX: MTM) shares are down 24% today. MTM shares have, in fact, been going down for some time now. Which rather shows that we were right to be worried about their newly fashionable aspect that two and a half months ago. 

The specific trigger for MTM's decline today is the announcement of some drilling results: “MTM Critical Metals Limited (ASX:MTM) (MTM or the Company) is pleased to advise that the diamond drilling program at the Pomme REE-Nb project in Québec, Canada (Pomme or the Project) is progressing rapidly since work recommenced in mid-July 2023 following

suspension of activities due to forest fires near the Project area. A further two drill holes (POM23-02 & POM-23-03) have been completed for a total of 744 metres of diamond drilling” Well, OK. But this is not exactly exciting news. 

Which is, we feel, what the problem is here. The MTM share price was elevated off the back of it being a new and exciting form. There was the name change, the pivot to new minerals. That's exciting - but the elevated share price that results from such excitement does require good news - not just so so - to be maintained.

MTM Critical Metals share price from Google Finance

As we've said before about MTM: “However, the bigger issue that worries us. Of course there are fashions in investing - there are fashions in everything human. So too are there fashons in what small exploration companies should go exploring for. At the grander level this is how capitalism works - prices change, people try to change what they supply in order to capture the profits from those prices. In this manner the changes in demand which changed the prices get met. It's a great and grand system overall.

“But like every fashion it's also possible to be a bit late to the party. MTM has moved from gold prospecting to rare earths and other critical metals (niobium, for example). Thus the name change. And we tend to think those parties are over. We know of several new niobium mines ready to roll. We know of at least 7 rare earths announcements on the ASX alone just in the past 6 weeks. By definition those are all projects which are a year or three in advance of where MTM is.” 

And then when you don't, in fact, immediately find something exciting that can rather take the air out of a ballooning share price. 

Note that we're not saying that MTM is not going to find critical metals - that area is a reasonable place to be exploring. Nor that it won't eventually come right, nor even that it will. Rather, that the past price - as we said - looked a little too excited for us. And so it has proved.