PSQ Holding (NASDAQ: PSQH) stock is down 43% from its recent post-IPO peak. PSQH stock seems, to us at least, to have had an excess of enthusiasm. We do in fact grasp the idea. That a community of the like minded can usefully - profitably - create an economic community. Being bound together by political or social mores is no more strange or odd than being bound together by geography or nationality. That very thing that ties can indeed be the thing which creates the market from which profits can be made. We're fine with that as an idea.
Where we get nervous is in the claimed ambition at PSQH: “But in the medium to longer term we don't think PublicSq is going to work. Again not because we're conservatives, or not or even anti-conservative. But because of this next desire: “"We are looking to build the alternative to Amazon, and we really believe with the help of our consumers and future investors that that's exactly what we can do," Seifert said. "We want to be a company that's by the people, for the people and owned by ‘we the people,' and that only happens if the people will rally around it and build it with us.” That is, we think, to misunderstand what Amazon is. Sure, we see the online marketplace and think that if we've got one of those then we can be like Amazon. But that's not what Amazon is, not at all. Really, the website is the last and least part - it's the network of warehouses, the skein of transport contracts that make Amazon. In fact, this is pretty much true of supermarkets themselves, places like Walmart. They're not retail companies - they're logistics companies. The beating heart, the tick tock that makes them work, is their ability to shift product, not the ability to create a crowd that wants to buy.
“PSQH as a social network, as a community of the like minded? Sure, and that also has a value. PublicSq as a new Amazon?” Our answer to that last is “No”. We don;t think that is going to work.

PSQ Holding stock price from NASDAQ
As we say, we're absolutely fine with the idea of a community of the like minded. We even do some work for conservative American causes ourselves. But we simply do not think that a valuation that tries to think that PSQH is the next Amazon, or even a competitor for that title, stands up. Sorry, but there it is. A community? Sure - a logistics giant, no.