AMC soars after hours, APE slumps - CEO takes to Twitter to offer new deal

AMC Entertainment (NYSE: AMC) shares leapt some 63% after hours on Friday. Concurrent with this the APE (NYSE: APE), or the AMC Preferred Equity Units, slumped as much as 63% and then largely recovered at the same time. The battle is all about the dilution of the common stock - and how AMC management just lost the latest round in the legal battle over it. 

The court ruling itself is fascinating: “The amendments were certain to pass because the AMC board of directors (the “Board”) had used its blank check authority to issue units representing fractional shares of preferred stock, and imbued those units with dispositive voting power. Those units have a mirrored voting feature under which any uninstructed units vote in proportion to the instructed units. The mirrored voting feature enables the

preferred units to dictate the outcome of any vote on which the common shares and

the preferred units vote together. During the leadup to the special meeting, the Board

sold a large block of preferred units to an institutional investor who promised to vote

in favor of the amendments.” That's really, pretty much stacking matters in favour of the board there. And what the Delaware Court decided, on Friday, was that they couldn't do that. 

AMC Entertainment stock price from NASDAQ

This then leads to the CEO posting the new offer on Twitter. Yep, corporate finance offers in the public square. Essentially, AMC must be able to raise new equity capital. If it doesn't it's likely to go bust - the actors' and writers' strike isn't helping, given the paucity of movies there might be in a year or two. Being able to issue new capital requires cleaning up the capital structure, that in turn almost certainly means some conversion of APE, the preferred equity, into AMC, the common equity. But the conversion of APE would mean substantial dilution of AMC stockholders. And there's the bind.

The deeper background to this is of course lockdown. Movie theater chains have vast overheads - if there's no income costs fall only a little. This is what - as well as horrendous starting debt levels - bankrupted Cineworld. Also what killed NCMI. The sector went into a tailspin that it's not obvious AMC can recover from. Yes, there was that glorious period of meme stock loveliness but they seem to have rather wasted that opportunity. What led a movie chain to invest in Hycroft, a gold miner (and not a good one) is difficult to divine.

The leap in AMC is as a result of the court ruling preventing that dilution by APE. For the moment at least. But this still leaves unsolved the question of how AMC survives into that medium term if it cannot raise equity capital. We thus rate AMC Entertainment as something that might well be interesting to speculate in. But it is going to be betting and not investing. This absolutely is not a position to buy and then tuck away in the corner to be looked at next year. Constant monitoring, at the very least, will be necessary.