Perpetual Resources (ASX: PEC) jumps 90% then falls back on lithium deal

Perpetual Resources (ASX: PEC) (OTC: PRESF) shares are currently up 40% today. PEC shares rose 90% at one point and fell back sharply after that surge. The initial reaction to the news was clearly too much. It's even possible that the current level of interest is too much in fact. For the announcement is only that they've now got some ground to search for lithium. True, it might be nice ground to search for lithium, there could be lithium there. But there's been little to no exploration to date, the idea that there is lithium there is that, well, there's some in the area. Which isn't usually regarded as grand proof.

Perpetual does/did have a pretty good focus to our minds. Looking for high grade silica sands is a useful, even honourable, endeavour. All that silicon for computer chips and solar cells has to come from somewhere and it really is sand. But while beach sand can be used obviously everyone prefers high quality deposits of something purer.

It's also true that lithium is the very thing these days. Quite the fashion given the whole EV revolution. However, we're not particularly excited by the lithium boom simply because we're old enough to have seen this before. We expect the market to be oversupplied real soon now. There are just so many people looking and there's no physical shortage of lithium out there at all. 

Perpetual Resources share price from ASX

The announcement is here: “Perpetual has entered into a binding option agreement to acquire a highly prospective exploration tenement package in the mining friendly state of Minas Gerais in Brazil. These tenements are strategically situated within the highly prolific 'Eastern Brazilian Pegmatite District', which is renowned as one of the world's largest regions for hard-rock lithium spodumene deposits. Tenements are ~20km from the Tier 1 Grota do Cirilo spodumene mine owned and operated by NASDAQ and TSX-V-listed Sigma Lithium Corp (Sigma) with a market capitalisation of approximately C$5 billion and has a world-class lithium resource.”

Translated out of corporatespeak that says “We can go looking and these other guys found some 12 miles away”. Which is not the strongest investment case ever.

Now yes, that's too cynical. But given that we think the lithium market is going to move into oversupply soon enough - and thus the price will come back down - we don't think there's all that much value in a lithium exploration licence. Obviously, if they find a major deposit then there will be value then. But we're all subject to the usual exploration risks before that.

We'd be surprised if the Perpetual Resources share price holds up on this news.