Carvana (NASDAQ: CVNA) stock is up 31% this morning. CVNA stock is up based - largely but not entirely perhaps - on the back of the Q2 results. Those are good, or at least a useful improvement fro the last set and pointing in the same useful direction. However, the real determinant of the short term price is going to be the market reaction. Which isn't quite as dumb as it sounds - of course prices depend upon market reaction. But there's a specific one here to think about.
The results from Carvana: “Carvana, the nation's largest online used auto retailer, delivers the best quarter in company history for Adjusted EBITDA & total gross profit per unit, & also expects to achieve positive Adjusted EBITDA in the 3rd quarter, for a 2nd consecutive quarter.” and yes, that's lovely. Except adjusted EBITDA isn't quite the point of a company - profit is. And if they thought they were going to make a net profit they would have trumpeted that. They didn't so they don't so think.

Carvana stock price from NASDAQ
As we said about the Q1 results at Carvana: “But it's the predictions for Q2 that we might want to be a bit more wary of. Yes, it's for a profit, but only a “Company expects to achieve positive adjusted EBITDA in second quarter 2023”. And the problem there is that EBITDA is a pretty odd measure itself - before interest, depreciation and so on and so really not reflective of the full costs of being in business at all. Then an adjusted version of that, well,
adjustments could be anything at all - although they do have to explain them to us.” Yes, adjusted etc is nice, but where - and when - is the profit?
The real issue here though is that the stock price above is an over-reaction to the news itself. Company hits target really just doesn't normally lead to 31% price rises. The trick is that the short position is, by one measure, 55% of the outstanding stock. Not even of the free float, but of the outstanding. Which makes what the shorts do a much greater influence on the CVNA stock price than anything else. That also explains that rise this morning, somewhat in anticipation.
If the shorts decide that, well, Carvana has beaten them, they close their positions and go home then CVNA could soar. More than it already has in anticipation. If, however, they grump that adjusted EBITDA isn't the thing, that the business idea itself is a crock and hold - or even add - to their positions then we could see a considerable fallback from here
This is all complicated by the debt deal announced today as well. That's also positive news - but again the important thing will be the reaction of the short sellers to that news. Is a $1.2 billion debt reduction going to be enough?
The short position at Carvana is so large that what those shorts do in the face of the Q2 results is going to determine the CVNA stock price. So, try to guess that reaction if you wish.