ITM Power (LON: ITM) is London’s most shorted share - probably rightly too

ITM Power (LON: ITM) (OTCPK: ITMPF) shares are London's most shorted. The ITM share problem is that the company is pretty much a binary play here. There's a very good argument that they're in the right place, the right technology in the middle of a boom for the sector. There's also the argument that they're ever so fractionally off being right and are therefore going to end up doing perhaps nothing, or near nothing. So, ITM Power could be worth much more than it is - or much less. That's what we mean by the binary position here. If matters continue as they are then it's not worth that current price but then, well, are matters going to so continue?

As to what is done at ITM Power: “ITM Power Plc designs, manufactures, and sells hydrogen energy systems for energy storage, transportation, and industrial sectors in the United Kingdom, Germany, Australia, rest of Europe, and the United States. It offers HGas1SP, HGas3SP, 3MEP CUBE, and 2GEP Skid.” The real heart of the business is PEM based electrolysis systems. These crack water into hydrogen and oxygen using electricity as the power sources. There really is a very strong logical case that this is quite the coming technology. As it happens one where we ourselves, in years past, have done some research (that is, actual playing in labs, not just reading about it). The world needs something to operate as a battery for unreliable wind and solar electricity generation. Electrolysed, or “green” hydrogen can be that battery. Take the excess generation and make hydrogen, when the wind stops blowing then run the H2 back through a fuel cell and generate electricity. As a logical system this works - ah, but does it work economically?

ITM Power share price from London Stock Exchange

The ITM share price is based upon the idea that yes, this will indeed work economically. And that ITM has one of the major parts of such a system, those electrolysers. Which they might do. But it's that hope that they do which gives us a valuation of some 125 times revenues. Which is really startlingly high on any other grounds. 

Given the vast interest in hydrogen right now - as the fault lines in other power systems are becoming more obvious - they might grow into this valuation as well. But that would require serious evidence of rising sales, not something greatly in evidence so far. 

It's also possible that they're slightly off. They're concentrated on PEM tech - which is intellectually justifiable. But it might be that SOFC (no, don't worry about exactly what these mean) tech actually wins out. Therefore those sales never do soar and if that happens at some point the hope built into ITM's stock price will fall away.

We don't know which way this is going to go. Nor, really, does anyone else. But we do have that rather binary option in ITM's price. Either it becomes a central part of the new energy system or it falls away as an also ran having bet on the wrong technological horse. The short position is intellectually justifiable - even if no one at all knows whether it is actually correct.