Petro Matad (LON: MATD) (OTCPK: PRTDF) shares are down 15% this morning on the news of a dry well. MATD shares would be running the other way if there were oil there of course. This all being an interesting example of how, while geology has got a lot better, it's not perfect as yet. Yes, we can 3D model the underground now, we can make assumptions and inveigle information out of all sorts of science. But there's still no substitute for actually digging a hole and seeing. That becomes the ultimate test of all mineral exploration. This applies to metallic elements, mineral sands, gemstones and yes, oil and gas. Whatever we might think, whatever might be indicated, at some point someone's got to go dig a hole and see.
Given this uncertainty that also means that no bank is ever going to finance mineral exploration through debt. Because until that hole is dug there is no asset to pay against that debt. This then means that all mineral exploration is, by definition, funded through shareholder capital. Sure, in a producing company, with some revenue, that can be done internally - instead of paying everything out in dividends keep some to use for further exploration. Or, with junior miners (those not producing as yet is a good definition) through constant issues of new capital to cover these exploration costs.

Petro Matad share price from London Stock Exchange
There is a certain amusement to the Petro Matad announcement: “The well came in close to prognosis at all levels. The primary objective Late Jurassic/Early Cretaceous Undur Formation was encountered at 1170m and had good quality reservoir sands interbedded with shales over a c. 200m interval. In the secondary objective Early Cretaceous Shinehudag Formation, three thick sand units were drilled with average porosity of around 18%. Good quality electric wireline logs confirmed both objectives to be water wet. The well will now be plugged and abandoned and the rig will be demobilised. Operations were carried out on time and as budgeted with the full support and cooperation of the local community.”
Everything was done really well and we were surrounded by happy smiling locals. It's just that there was no oil there.
Oh well, this happens. And for us as investors we need to take this as a reminder of the risks attached to resource exploration. At some point someone really does need to dig the hole to see and sometimes there just isn't that desired thing to see at the bottom of the hole.