Magnum Mining (ASX: MGU) is a bit of a bet upon green political subsidies

Magnum Mining and Exploration (ASX: MGU) shares are up 18% on news from the US. MGU shares are being affected by news of the roadtrip taken by senior management to see what the American interest in their twin projects is, also to gauge whether a secondary listing in New York might be appropriate. Given the US concentration of the projects then that  secondary listing on either the NYSE or NASDAQ might well make sense. But it's worth remaining ourselves that the series of projects as a whole do depend more upon how green everyone wants to be than anything else. And, obviously, the funding that might be available for being green.

As we say, there's nothing wrong with being green or even with targeting green subsidies. But it is worth knowing that this is the base of the business idea here. Iron mining isn't quite the point. The Buena Vista magnetite project only really makes sense if there's a market for DRI produced iron. Magnum has already signed up Mitsubishi as the offtake partner for that - but note that's on an “if” basis. If production starts then Mitsubishi will take the material. “ As to the larger background of the project there are merits here, yes. Green iron is going to be a thing, climate change means we'd prefer not to have to use blast furnaces and their associated coke. Magnetite and HIsmelt are indeed one of the ways we can gain green iron. The idea is just fine - it's the details of the implementation which are going to matter though. For the ore is easily available elsewhere, the technology doesn't belong to Magnum either. So, others can do much the same thing if they wish - therefore the determinant of success is not the idea but how well Magnum implements it. The entire project relies upon management efficiency that is.” Well, OK.


Magnum Mining share price from ASX

The other part of the project is even more reliant upon greenery: “Magnum's Appalachian Iron Project in West Virginia is planned to produce net zero carbon green steel by converting locally sourced and sustainably produced biomass into biochar to offset the carbon emissions from pig iron production. Waste heat from the process is expected to be used to cogenerate green power. On 17 May, 2023 Magnum announced a submission to the Appropriations committee of the US Senate in application for Congressionally Directed Spending for applied research related to the project. This was done through the office of, and supported by, Senator Manchin of West Virginia.”

That money might well arrive too. But that entire project depends upon there being a viable offsets scheme. Which is, in turn, something entirely dependent upon US domestic politics. 

This isn't to have a downer on Magnum Mining. What it is is to point out that it's not really about mining at all. It's about the politics of green subsidies. Invest or trade on that, correct, basis.