Coinbase (NASDAQ: COIN) stock has done well recently. COIN stock is off just a quarter percent this morning after the digestion, over the weekend, of the decision on Ripple. We think that this is an interesting decision, yes, but we don't think that it's going to stand. Yes, we know that the law grinds small and slow but we do rather run with the walks like a duck, quacks like a duck idea of defining something. So, we're bear on those who make markets in crypto - simply because we think the end result is going to be, well, yes, of course they're securities.
We base this not on any great knowledge of the law but rather on politics. There is no great backing for crypto within the bureaucracy that matters, the SEC. Therefore we expect cases to continue to be filed showing that crypto coins are, in fact, securities. Therefore the SEC should regulate them and therefore they need to be registered with the SEC before they are sold. Those who have done that without doing so are therefore going to get it in the next - sooner or later.
Do note that this is a belief, not a fact. A belief driven by our rather jaundiced view of how politics and bureaucracies work - not by anything so detailed as a knowledge of the relevant law.

Coinbase stock price from NASDAQ
The news is that a judge has ruled that sometimes Ripple is a security, sometimes it is not: “A U.S. judge's ruling helped buoy the cryptocurrency sector on Thursday, especially alt-coins such as solana (SOL-USD), cardano (ADA-USD), and litecoin (LTC-USD). The ruling found that Ripple Labs' crypto asset XRP (XRP-USD) can be considered a security in some cases and not a security in others.”
The market seems to be taking this as, well, what if Coinbase - and others - are only trading in Ripple when it's not a security? And this then spills over into all of the other coins and COIN itself will be just fine. That's not the way we think the SEC will interpret this - and we base this purely on how we think bureaucracies work, not any inside knowledge. What's likely to happen next is that as Ripple sometimes is a security then Ripple always needs to be registered as a security with the SEC. Which opens up the trading firms to that whole big world of pain all over again.
That is, we think that the SEC will claim that because Ripple - and thus other coins - is sometimes a security then they fall within the SEC's jurisdiction and always need to be registered there. Whether the SEC succeeds in that claim will be another thing but that is the way we think they'll try it. And that will lead to another world of regulatory pain for the marketplaces like Coinbase.