Narryer Metals (ASX: NYM) shares are up 17% on a Canadian lithium deal. NYM shares are up on the excitement of taking over some lithium prospects in Canada. For a company as small as Narryer this is an important deal. But for the larger concept of lithium exploration, well, we think that idea is getting more than a little tired. This tends to be how metals investment booms go - lots of excitement but those late to the game tend not to - tend only, mind you - do all that well out of it.
The specific deal announced by Narryer: “Narryer acquires portfolio of prospective projects to explore for Lithium-CaesiumTantalum type pegmatites, in the James Bay, Abitibi and NW Ontario regions, Canada” This is, of course a part of that more general hunt for spodumene. This has its implications in several different ways. The first and most obvious being that yes, these areas are prospective for that mineral. That doesn't mean there's anything there in economic quantity but they're not trying to do a cucumbers out of Moonshine thing here.
The second is that the economics of spodumene are quite specific. Shareholder capital - that's us out here - has to cover all of the exploration costs, up to and including the preparation of the definitive feasibility study. But the actual mine and concentrator production is usually - at least in part - paid for by the spodumene concentrate processor, in the form of a prepayment for an offtake contract. That alleviates some of the future pressure on shareholders - although, obviously, this only comes into play if the exploration proves out.

Narryer Metals share price from ASX
It's the final issue which weighs most heavily with us though. Which is that lithium has clearly been most fashionable in recent years. The big companies already producing at volume - Pilbara, Albemarle - are making fortunes. So, there's an awful lot of exploration going on. In fact, there are hundreds of exploration companies out there looking for lithium. Many of them will find it too, in economic concentrations. Simply because it's not that rare a metal nor is the major hard rock source, spodumene, difficult to either find or mine.
No, this doesn't mean that everyone who goes looking is going to find an economic deposit. But it does mean that many among the larger number looking will. That, in turn, has implications for the future lithium price. Our read on this is that lithium supply will exceed demand soon enough and then that lithium price will fall. Or, to be a little more cagey about it, we do not expect the current scarcity value to persist.
A small explorer like Narryer would of course rise hugely on confirmation of an economic find. But for us the glory days of even a hunt of lithium produced in share price boom are rather over.