Panthera Resources, PAT, down 20%, is having an unexpected problem, a dangerous one

Panthera Resources (LON: PAT) shares are down 20% this morning. PAT shares have fallen on an announcement about the arbitration case it's hoping to bring. This could be just a paperwork problem, that is always possible. But it's also, well, it could be a significantly dangerous problem for Panthera. A significant part of the assumed value of Pantera is tied up in possible winnings from that arbitration case. But of course no one's really that interested in piling further capital into PAT shares in order to fund it. Thus the attempt to use a litigiation funding company to, well, to fund the litigation.

But therein lies the potential problem for PAT: “Gold exploration and development company Panthera Resources Plc (AIM: PAT), with assets in West Africa and India, provides an update on Indo Gold Pty Ltd's conditional arbitration funding agreement (AFA) for up to US$10.5 million in litigation financing with LCM Funding SG Pty Ltd (LCM), as originally announced by the Company on 28th February 2023. Most recently, on 1 June 2023 the Company announced, amongst other matters, that it had agreed to an extension to 30 June 2023 to allow LCM to complete its detailed due diligence (the "LCM Due Diligence").  While the Company previously did not anticipate a further extension of the due diligence period, the Company confirms that it has agreed to a further extension to the LCM Due Diligence period to 14 July 2023. Following the successful completion of LCM Due Diligence, the parties can then move to complete a Funding Confirmation Notice.  There can be no assurance that LCM's due diligence will be completed to LCM's satisfaction.”

Now, what they mean here by “due diligence” is “do we want to risk our money on this case?”

Panthera Resources share price from London Stock Exchange

Which is what the problem is for Panthera. Sure, it could all just be the paperwork, the senior sign off partner's off on his hols or something. But a second delay? Well, some might start to think that they're not all that keen on the case. 

Start from the beginning again. Panthera is really sure they've got a case. They've been hard done by. But it's also true that Panthera have sunk costs here. They know they're only going to get those back by litigation - they're invested in this already. LCM, the litigation funders however, they're not invested yet. They're taking the decision as to whether to invest or not. Their reading of the case is going to be a lot more objective therefore. And they'll only take a case they think - on the balance of probabilities and costs - they've a change of winning. 

So, what happens if LCM decline to fund the case? Then our estimates of the value of the arbitration case plummet, don't they? And the longer LCM take to make up their mind the worse the Panthera case looks.