IOG drops 40% - we’ve not got much gas and the gas price is falling to boot

IOG (LON: IOG) shares are down 40% in London Wednesday morning. The problem is, really, that they've not got much gas and also the price for the gas they have got is falling, rapidly. The combination is not, perhaps, fatal but it's most certainly not helpful. There's a serious risk of breaching bond covenants in the near future.

It's possible to divine in this the basic problem with any and every commodity producer. We know that it's not fashionable to say this any more but there really isn't any shortage of anything out there. There's coal, gas, oil, minerals, metals, all over the place. We have no physical shortages of any of them. We do and can have shortages of people currently producing them. We can and do have shortages of them at a price. But actual physical shortages, no. Further, the definition of a commodity is that the producers are price takers. What they can sell for is something determined by the market, not management techniques.

All of this just does mean that commodity producers can get into the sorts of problems that IOG now has. Spending money at the top of the cycle to gain more supply but then finding that - as here - perhaps supply isn't so good and also they're trying to sell into a declining price with what they have got.

IOG share price from London Stock Exchange

The announcement itself: “The gas market environment has become increasingly challenging over recent months. In January 2023, the Company's average realized gas price was 214 p/therm. When the 2022 Annual Report and Accounts ("ARA") was released on 16 March 2023, the UK NBP Day-ahead gas price was 126 p/therm. This then fell to 64 p/therm by 6 June 2023. The average realized price for May 2023 was 72 p/therm and 2023 realized average to the end of May was 112 p/therm.” There is also that little difficulty with the two gas wells: “The well has flowed at a maximum dry gas rate of 22.8 mmscf/d and 280-336 bbl/d condensate at the export pipeline pressure of 1250psi, with no formation water observed. This is an improvement on current H1 rate, but below the expected initial H2 gas rate of 30-40 mmscf/d” The one well isn't producing well (aha) and the second not as well as expected. And, as above, the price paid for that declining production is falling off a cliff.

Naturally this is causing likely breaches of borrowing covenants - those borrowings were agreed at much higher gas prices. 

The fall in the IOG share price looks fully justified here - and there's little to suggest that it's going to turn around swiftly either.