Top Financial up 18% - here we go again, sigh

Top Financial (NASDAQ: TOP) is up 18% again and there's really no good reason for this at all. OK, so people are buying more stock, that's the only reason stock prices ever do go up. So there's the reason - buying. But once we step past that platitude into trying to examine why there's more buying there isn't a good reason. What's happening here is someone trying to revive that meme stock idea. This is all most fun, of course it is, but it's an area of speculation fraught with danger. 

The basic background here is that a few Far East (and often Hong Kong or China based) financial stocks have briefly soared in recent times. Think of the AMTD Twins where one of them was, for a brief few days, worth more than Goldman Sachs. That idea was very silly indeed but it did happen before fading back. But fads and fashions do pass through stock markets simply because markets are made up of humans. It's only necessary to look at any men's or women's clothing magazine to see that humans can be convinced to do some very silly things in the name of fashion.

So, what then happens is that if one HK financial can soar then why can't other HK financials soar? And if the market capitalisation of the stock is low enough then the mere act of buying in volume will make that stock price soar. So, given this, some HK financials do soar. Well, OK, but now comes the danger.

Top Financial stock price from NASDAQ

If a price is moved purely by fashion then when fashion changes so will that price again. And human fashion can turn on a dime - as anyone wearing loon pants 3 months after the change to bell bottoms will have found out to their embarrassment.

So, it's necessary to examine the fashionable stock to see whether there's anything there other than that meme stock and fashion? Sometimes there is - Hertz really did come back from Chapter 11 with a positive value. So, what about Top Financial?

Well, there's nothing wrong with the business. It's a futures and options broker, which is a perfectly respectable business to be in. But it's a broker. It's not taking positions itself, so there's no possibility of reading the market right and so gaining some vast capital gain. Revenue is the straight fees from handling the paperwork of trades. And that's it. It's always a relatively low margin business, there will be no vast expansion of it. Could be a perfectly sensible investment in fact. But it's simply not a stock that would ever justify the vast values placed upon it by that brief time as a meme stock.

So, what's happening here? We'd suggest just some more of that speculation. All most fun but not something that's likely to last.