Pan African Resources Down 21% - deep problem is destruction of SA economy

Pan African Resources (LON: PAF) shares are down on the release of the production update. Much of which is the usual mixture of successes and failures in a mature mining business. Mature here, in mining, is used as the opposite to “junior” - a mature business is producing something, a junior is not. The two business ideas are near entirely different even as we call them both “mining”. One is an engineering challenge, how to do this thing effectively and efficiently. The other has more than a bit of luck to it - is there actually any interesting metal in the area we're looking at?

Pan African's operations, as we say, have some good parts and some bad to them. The Evander Mines operations hit a run of low grade ore, just one of those things that happens. The ramp up at Barberton is going slower than expected. On the other hand the Mintails Project looks about to be licenced. And given the general performance of South Africa's economy the rand to $ exchange rate fell substantially, raising the rand income from selling the company's gold production. 

So, a mixed bag. But there's one further issue here that is going to cause problems for Pan African and should also colour our views of others operating in South Africa.

 Pan African Resources share price from London Stock Exchange

That issue is this: “Challenges related to Eskom generated electricity supply, resulting in a production loss of approximately 10,000oz of gold” Well, that's about 5% of production so annoying but not fatal. Except it also leads to this: “In addition to load curtailment, power outages and surges, difficulties related to transformers and other Eskom infrastructure contributed to production disruptions. As per the announcement released on 15 May 2023, Pan African is aggressively rolling out its renewable energy plans in order to mitigate the impact of this challenge.”

Basically, Jacob Zuma's government (to make the accusation about only one SA government) so looted the industrial infrastructure of the country that even the industrial electricity supply is no longer guaranteed. For a country that relies upon mining for a substantial portion of export earnings this could be a fatal mistake.

Yes, OK, Pan African can spend a lot more money on gaining access to considerably expensive more reliable electricity. But if that's what's necessary to gain reliable supply then so be it. Margins might reduce but gold production can continue, even rise. But now think if the effect of this upon the entire South African economy. We need to be calibrating down our expectations for everyone else who works and consumes electricity in that economy. That's the real lesson of this PAF production release - the looming possibility of a wider economic breakdown in South Africa.