Hammerson, HMSO, now among top 5 most shorted stocks in London - again

Hammerson (LON: HMSO) (OTCPK: HMNSF) shares might be in for another battering. Or at least that's where some of the possibly smart money is positioning itself. For Hammerson shares are now among the top 5 most shorted in London. At which point we might think no, not again? For the Hammerson performance has been, to put it mildly, dreadful over the past 5 years. Pretty much a 90% destruction of value which isn't what we'd expect - or want - from a mature and dividend paying property company. As safe as houses doesn't seem to cut it - although if HMSO had been in houses this wouldn't have happened.

Now, to be fair, the short position rising to 4.6% of the outstanding stock doesn't prove anything about the future. It just tells us the views of some about that future. They're confident enough that Hammerson shares are going to decline again that they've sold now in the hope of buying back cheaper later. To do so they've got to borrow the shares from elsewhere and that's what's tracked, the borrow. You only do this when you think that the share price is likely to decline.

Hammerson share price from London Stock Exchange 

Being short Hammerson would have worked for much of the past 5 years, as we can see. But clearly being short now means belief in more of an HMSO share price fall to come.

The basic Hammerson problem is that it's being hit by two structural changes at the same time. The rise of internet shopping means that the retail premises it owns are worth less. In fact, we can roughly track the empty shop rate by the percentage of retail sales that are online. Britain has too many shops it would seem. That all jumped in lockdown but bricks and mortar have bounced back from those lows. We've still the structural decline though.

The other part of the business, office space, was thought resistant to this effect. But lockdown inspired much more experimentation on working from home. That's left office space all over the country empty, or at least much less used. Lockdown seems to have been the trigger for the structural change here. 

Hammerson's basic problem is that owning office and retail space in Britain just isn't a good thing to be doing these days. At least, owning such bought at the top of the markets a few years back isn't. Whether the shorts are right and this presages another disaster in the HMSO share price is another matter. But it is actually possible. INTU went bust after all, under little more than the same set of pressures hitting up against debt constraints.