Brainchip Holdings, BRN, drops 18% on losing a shareholder vote

Brainchip Holdings (ASX: BRN) is one of those shares representing the glorious new world of artificial intelligence. As such the outcome is pretty binary. Because that's what outcomes usually are in a field where technology is advancing in leaps and bounds. Either this specific implementation gets incorporated into the general platform the world uses or it's left in the dust by those that are. This is simply the way that all previous technological revolutions have worked as well. Sure, we can look around and see HP, or Microsoft, Amazon, as examples of huge companies that grew out of varied stages of the computing revolution. But there are at least tens of thousands of companies that tried and didn't, in fact, make it in the same markets over the same periods of time. 

Another way to put the same point is that it might well be steam engine time with respect to AI. But what that means is that there are many people able to try all sorts of different approaches because that's just what is meant by “steam engine time”. All of the associated technologies have matured to where the new thing can be done - but all of those associated technologies are also available to everyone else.

Brainchip Holdings share price from ASX

As it happens the Brainchip Holdings implementation is interesting. By putting much of the AI onto a specific chip - doing things in hardware is efficient after all - it should be possible to gain a large reduction both in computing costs and also response times and latency. However, it's also true that inserting operations into hardware risks being left behind in any fast moving field. Hardware does take time to develop and running new code in the cloud is always going to be faster in the development cycle. Hardware implementations require, almost as a definition, a certain stability of what is to be encoded into the hardware.

As it also happens Brainchip has just had its annual general meeting. Which is where the shareholders get to vote on varied matters to do with the running of what is, after all, their company. The embarrassment is that they voted down the remuneration report. Effectively, they've said that they don't agree with how much management is getting paid. Since the company does belong to the shareholders and the management are the employees of the shareholders this rather stings.

Thus the fall in the share price. 18% off the market capitalisation might seem a lot. But there's clearly a breakdown in that relationship between the corporate owners and the hired managers - that's not the sort of thing that bodes well for peaceful development of the business.