On The Beach, OTB, drops 18% on better, but not good enough, result

On The Beach (LON: OTB) shares dropped 18% in London on Tuesday on the back of their interim results. Which could be viewed as odd, because the results were in fact better. So why such a drop? The answer - obviously enough - being that while the results were better they weren't good enough. Sure, gross revenues came forward by 28%, group revenue by 38%, gross profit by 29% - everything's moving in the right direction at least. Except losses only declined from £7 million to £6 million. Which isn't so good.

There's a little trick to OTB's accounts that we must investigate. Some of the group's business is as principal - they organise the trip, pay for it and get paid for it. Rather more of the group's business is as an agent. It's worth noting that their profit as principal is tiny, even if it's up 100% on the half year. But the really big difference here is revenue recognition. Principal business is recognised when the trip is taken, as agent when it's booked and paid for.

This matters for the standard for a European holiday company - and this includes the airlines - is to make a loss over the winter and then a bigger profit over the summer. But OTB doesn't work that way, not quite. For when it books as an agent in the winter for someone's summer holiday it's recognising that revenue immediately. So we can't just swoon with relief at the winter losses being so low - as we would with an airline - because that's not the way the accounting is done. 

On The Beach share price from London Stock Exchange

The real issue here though is lockdown. Obviously all travel businesses got hit hard by that. We're also seeling from the short haul airlines that they've bounced back. Revenues and profits are vastly up this year as compared to last - when we still had uncertainty over what travel rules were going to be. Even the long haul airlines like IAG are seeing leisure travel back to old levels.

So what we're looking for at OTB is something similar. We want to see organic growth, obviously, we need to see keeping up with inflation as well. But we also want to see soaring business volume as a result of the ending of lockdown. And that's the thing that isn't obvious in these accounts. We're hoping for something much better in the business comeback and we're not seeing that surge that we hope for. To repeat, we would like to see a surge well above last year's levels as a result of the cyclical return from lockdown.

In normal times we'd probably accept these results as being good enough. Today we don't, thus the share price drop.