PacWest Bancorp (NASDAQ: PACW) stock dropped 22% again late yesterday. The trigger seems to have been the balance sheet revelations in the latest report. Which is where we get to that banking conundrum. PacWest might, maybe, need liquidity support from the regulatory system. So, sensibly, it has gone out and made sure that it has such liquidity available if it should need it. The market is then reading that as this precautionary stance proves that PacWest does need that liquidity.
And as banking works that, in turn, means that PacWest Bancorp might actually need the liquidity support. It's something of a no win feedback loop here. Precautionary activities, the just in case arrangements, can bring on the very thing that is to be protected against.
PacWest is doing sensible things. They've slashed their dividend to a purely nominal $0.01. That preserves capital. They've pledged $5 billion and change of loans to the Federal Reserve Bank to gain access to just under $4 billion in liquidity. But that's precautionary, it's a “what if?” action. But that's exactly what people are worrying about, the no smoke without fire argument. Confidence is vital in banking.

PacWest Bancorp stock price from NASDAQ
As we've pointed out before PacWest's hold to maturity book is what matters for the capital base of the bank. Currently that seems fine. But that might only be true as long as it doesn't have to sell it off in a fire sale in order to gain liquidity to pay off depositors. So, organising greater liquidity through the FRB in order to not have to crystalise any losses there seems like an excellent prudential idea. But what appears to be happening is that the market is taking that prudential action as evidence that the book might have to be sold off, thereby damaging the capital base.
There's really no way out of this, no leap that can be made which resolves the problem. PacWest will muddle along and survive or it won't. And it's the behaviour of depositors which will determine this. So, which way do we think the depositors will jump?