Meteoric Resources, MEI, now up 1,000% on valuation of Caldeira rare earths

Meteoric Resources (ASX: MEI) shares are now up some 1,000%  from their December levels. This is one of those ten baggers that make junior miners such an interesting speculative space. It's certainly true that a rare earths find has value - just look at that 10x rise in the share price. But it is necessary to ask at some point, well, just how valuable is a rare earths find? The problem here not being the valuation or richness of any one specific find. It's that with all of these minor metals the valuation is driven by however many other people find similar deposits, or even different ways of gaming access to the same end product.

We are therefore bears on rare earths. Yes, we know, this is very contrarian. We all know that the electrification of the world is going to require many times current global production of the magnet metals - the magnet rare earths. So, demand is going to rise, current prices - just current prices - are eyewatering by historic standards. So why be bear on the market? Simply because those high prices are driving a vast amount of exploration work. The outcome of which is that rare earths just aren't very rare.

Meteoric Resources share price from ASX.

We've talked about Meteroic Resources before. Also MEI here. We don't doubt that Caldeira is a significant rare earths find. That's not our worry at all. 

Our view is definitely coloured by experiences 10 and 15 years back. There was a rare earths boom following the 2010 restrictions on Chinese exports. At one point (from Jack Lifton) there were 420 rare earths projects looking for finance. Two came to production. Lynas and Molycorp and that was enough to depress prices back below 2010 levels. Nothing wrong with either of the Mt Weld or Mountain Pass deposits. It's just that the two competing produced enough to drop prices. Drop them so much that Molycorp went bust and Lynas had to be refinanced.

The current rare earths work is not just finding new deposits, it's finding entirely new kinds of deposits - the ionic clays. Our worry is therefore not over any specific deposit - not even Caldeira. It's that there are so many newly uncovered deposits that we're not all that sure that any of them have that much value.