Baidu, BIDU, up 4.25% in Hong Kong - but does this lead or follow NASDAQ?

Baidu (HK: 9888) (NASDAQ: BIDU) has at least two market quotes, one in Hong Kong, the other on NASDAQ. The two markets are, of course, in about as different time zones as it is possible to get. With some paperwork and effort - and time gap - the two stocks are arbitrageable across the two markets. Given standard finance and economic theory we would therefore expect the two quotations to move if not in lockstep then at least closely together. Because if any substantial price gap opens up then it's possible to profit by buying in one market and selling in the other, that very action being what would bring the two prices into alignment. 

OK, but which one leads the other? As it happens today 9888 is up 4.25% in Hong Kong. But BIDU was up 3.99% yesterday before close at 8pm. So, we'd like to try and know which is leading which? We could, for example, think that HK is much closer to China where the bulk of the Baidu business is and therefore information will hit there first. Or even, HK is the same time zone and therefore market moving information will arrive during the trading day there. That's a theory at least, but is it the correct one? 

Baidu share price from Hong Kong Stock Exchange

Worth noting that the HK price is in HKD, the US one in USD, they're not worth the same. The relationship between them is fixed though, so there are no FX rate problems here. BIDU is an ADR of several of the HK equity.

We might think that the market with the higher volume is really the one that determines the price. In that we'd probably be right too. New York traded 2.7 million shares yesterday, HK 5.88 million, so there we are then. Except the NY quote is those several of Baidu HK shares - there are 8 HK stock to one NY. Therefore the NY market quote is the one doing the higher volume in trade. 

Finally, it's possible to look at the HK share price in detail, as above. 09888 opened up and didn't vary much after that. So, it's probably true that yesterday's BIDU rose flowed through into the Hong Kong price.

This is not determinative but it's a useful working answer. The New York quote drives the Hong Kong one for Baidu. Which does make sense in another manner - why would a Chinese company float in New York if that's not where the investors are and the price determination exists?