BP falls - yes falls - 5% on better than expected profits

BP (LON: BP.) (NYSE: BP) shares actually dropped 5% this morning as the oil major reported profits better than expected. This normally works the other way around - produce an earnings beat and the share price rises. Quite what led to that fall is something we have to surmise. On the grounds that individual sellers do not in fact explain to us why they're selling. So we've got to try and work it out for ourselves. 

The BP results were good. $4.96 billion for Q1, which while not so exciting compared to a year ago were up on the expected $4.3 billion. Standard economic theory tells us that the share price before the announcement was based on that $4.3 number - so, beating that should push the shares up. Clearly, it didn't - so, why? 

One argument is that BP is slowing its share repurchsae program, $1.75 billion for this coming quarter, down from $2.75 billion last. That's a reduction in cash being returned to shareholders so perhaps that's it? 

BP share price from London Stock Exchange

It is possible just to put it down to that old adage about buy the rumour, sell the fact. The hope of better results pushes the share price up but when the facts arrive to confirm it it's all a bit anticlimactic perhaps.

We do have the one more theory here though. We're already seeing calls for the extra and punitive taxation of oil majors to be increased once again. These recent BP profits being used as one of the pieces of evidence to justify such a move. We'd not say that such a move is a certainty but it is certainly a possibility. So that would usefully explain the 5% share price drop. Fears that the better the profits the more likely it will be that they'll be taxed away.

We also don't think that should happen nor that it would be sensible if it did. But then politics has that uncanny ability of not being sensible about economics, doesn't it?