Admiral Group, ADM, up another 4.5% on changing sentiment - have they licked inflation?

Admiral Group (LON: ADM) shares suffered badly nearly a year back as it became obvious that insurance companies had an inflation problem. It's one of those things that is obvious once it's pointed out but which no one really thought about until it was. Worse than that, Admiral itself didn't really think about it until it was made very plain to them in their own internal numbers. The problem is that inflation - unexpected inflation that is - is a problem for an insurance company. 

Think on car insurance, which is where a lot of ADM's business is. Most car insurance contracts are for a year. Sure, many stay with the same insurance company for decades, but the contract price resets every year. In the pool of insured near all claims are paid out within that contract year. The float the insurance company gets to invest is thus = on average of course - invested for 6 months. That's OK, and the investment income from that does belong to Admiral. But not stick a jump in inflation into that. The price was set in January (say) and the costs of any repairs or payouts will hit in July (say, roughly the mean average of 1 year contracts). In a 1% inflation world that's fine. But in a newly 10% and more inflation world that means that by the time claims are paid out prices are 5% above those pertaining at the time the premium was set. 


Admiral Group share price from London Stock Exchange

Margins on underwriting are usually pretty tight - even negative in truly competitive markets - that investment income makes up for that. So, a 5% price change can have significant effects. Plus, as we know, the prices of used cars and even parts rose much more than general inflation during and after lockdown. Admiral did suffer from exactly this effect.

On the other hand when inflation is expected this can be built into premium prices at the get go. Further, if inflation - unexpectedly - falls then the effect goes into reverse. The recent rise in Admiral could well be to do with that general realisation that inflation has peaked, reversing this effect on ADM.