Bilibili down 5.5% - is this a creators strike?

Bilibili (HKG: 9629) (NASDAQ: BILI) stock is down 5.5% in Hong Kong on the day. The speculation - and it is just that, only speculation - that there is something of a creator's strike going on inside China. This being the result of the company's recent decision to change creator's terms. This is also hotly denied by at least some creators within China. So we might therefore think that this is just one of those stories that sweeps through markets from time to time.

This makes any position in Bilibili shares difficult to determine. For there is plenty of other news which seems more positive. There's the launch of a new blockchain initiative for example. JP Morgan has expected Bilibili shares to jump based upon hotter games launches. There's the general excitement around China online stocks given the Alibaba demerger plan. But all the same the BILI price is down that 5.5% on the day.

Bilibili stock proce from Hong Kong Stock Exchange

The current set of stories is coming from Mainland media. That some number of creators are refusing to - perhaps just not doing so - create content for the platform. This is driven by a change in the payout terms they receive for doing so. In this first instance it doesn't quite matter whether this is true - if people believe it then prices will move. That greater profitability could come at the cost to some creators is obvious enough. But we, of course, are interested in the profit, not the creators, so this could go either way. Fewer creators at a better margin to Bilibili might be a good deal for BILI, might not be. One of those things we'll have to wait and see.

It is true though that some analysts are changing their opinion. Bernstein has just downgraded BILI to underperform from market perform for example.

The usual caveats apply to short term price movements here. It could just be stories sweeping through the market. It could be some change in the underlying prospects of the company. Until we work out which it is then it's difficult to know whether this price fall is something that will reverse or not.