Lynas Rare Earths (ASX: LYC) should be in a dominant position in the rare earths market. The only non-China fully integrated rare earths producer at a time when the world desires ever more of those rare earths. That's not quite how it does work out of course for the biggest determinant of long term success is how many other rare earth producers will there be? Despite what we might think rare earths are just another commodity after all. Producers are price takers, the more miners there are then the lower price will go.
We should also consider that rare earths are not rare (nor earths) and that there are many possible sources. So, being the current dominant producer, as Lynas is, is not a permanent position. This has happened before as well. As we pointed out elsewhere back in 2010, that China restricts exports doesn't matter in the long term. Because new mines can open and indeed Lynas did so, as did Mountain Pass reopen. Rare earth prices were soon enough below where they had been before Chinese export restrictions. At one point Jack Lifton estimated that there were 420 different rare earth projects looking for finance

Lynas Rare Earths share price from ASX
This time around there's even more competition. For new geologies are being explored, not just new places to mine the same old ores. As we've noted about OD6 and Meteoric, the ionic clays appear to be globally distributed and they will be an excellent source of the magnet rare earths. It is entirely non-obvious that rare earth prices are going to stay elevated over time. Of course, not all of those other projects are going to succeed - Pensana looks like it's running out of money already.
The important point to grasp here is that yes. Lynas is a large, integrated, miner of minerals that everyone currently wants. But the price it can sell at depends upon how many other people try to do the same thing. It's a commodity producer, a price taker. So, the more new mines open - or even look like opening - the more weakness we should expect in the Lynas Rare Earths share price. For there really are a lot of rare earths out there.