Metropolitan Bank suffers 27% from Vidar short report - recovers 14% premarket

Metropolitan Bank (NYSE: MCB) suffered badly yesterday from a shot-selling report from Vidar. The start of the Vidar analysis is that Metropolitan looks very much like Signature and Silicon Valley to them. Therefore it's likely to share the same fate as SIVB and so on. The prediction does trend toward MCB going to zero. 

In more detail, Metropolitan has considerable linkage into the crypto world both by issung debit cards for crypto firms and also more directly in the crypto business. Vidar also thinks the balance sheet looks very like that of SBNY and that it is bleeding deposits. Well, it's a thesis, obviously. And given current worries about banks in general a thesis coming from anyone with some heft in the market is going to move prices. It being one of the great truths that banking only survives because of confidence in banks - lose that and the bank itself is lost. 

Metropolitan Bank stock price from NASDAQ

As we can see MCB suffered back when Signature and Silicon Valley got into problems then recovered as the FDIC and Fed stated that - for the moment at least - there is full deposit insurance.

Perhaps the most telling of the Vidar points is that Metropolitan is near entirely lending into the commercial real estate market. This might not be quite where we'd like deposits to be going these days. Further, it's a pretty illiquid market to try and get money back from if that needs to be done in a hurry. 

This is not to say that there will be a run. But it is to say that if there is then the FDIC might start to think that the problem is a little more than just liquidity - what would the losses on CRE be if called early or the loan value crystalised by a sale? 

The market in general seems to be dismissing most of these worries this morning as MCB stock rises again. But whether that will hold? The larger point for us all here being that any bank is vulnerable to short-sellers right now. The general worry about the sector simply makes that true.