Perhaps Not - Phoenix Copper’s Big Boast Is Its ESG Qualifications

Phoenix Copper (LON: PXC) (OTCQX: PXCLY) gives us an interesting little look at how some corporate managements think they can maximise shareholder value. This may or may not coincide with what we think might maximise shareholder value and as we're the shareholders - or at least the potential ones - what we think is what matters for our decision making.

The issue here is ESG commitments - environmental, social and governance. This is rather the new fashionable thing in the investment world. The argument is that we investors are very concerned about all that social equity and don't hurt the bunnies stuff. If this is true - if - then corporate valuations will be maximised by obeying all of the rules and strictures surrounding ESG. It's also possible that it's not true, that ESG is some elite preoccupation and that we out here are really only interested in the cash side of the business, If that's true then ESG is detrimental to market capitalisation as its effort being spent on things we're not interested in.   

Phoenix Copper share price from London Stock Exchange

Which brings us to Phoenix Copper's corporate update which dropped today. When discussing the coming annual report and profits the first thing they tell us about is their ESG work: “The Company continues to strengthen its Environmental, Social & Governance ("ESG") credentials and is pleased to report that it has obtained an overarching score of 'A' on Digbee ESG,” at which point the share price drops 22% and change. Yes, of course, there could be other issues here (largely to do with the fact that not much else seems to be happening) but this isn't a strong confirmation of how attention paid to ESG issues increases the corporate valuation now, is it? 

We could even take this to be a variation on the Ralph Waldo Emerson line - the louder he talked of his honour the faster we counted the spoons. The more a company prioritises their ESG work and credentials then the more we should look at their actual performance. But that would be to be cynical and we certainly should never be that about money, should we?