QualTek isn’t going to be like Hertz you know, really, it’s in Chapter 11

QualTek (NASDAQ: QTEK) stock is a little more normal on Wednesday, down 20% in premarket trade. That also brings it down 40% or so from yesterday's absurd high. As we said yesterday about QualTek it's in Chapter 11. This means that it's most, most unlikely that there will be any recovery for equity. “To an extent the Chapter 11 filing was a pre-pack. “pre-pack, QualTek said, “The Debtors anticipate that the Plan will enjoy the overwhelming support of its creditors, eliminates approximately $312 million of the Company's funded debt, leaves trade creditors unimpaired, and provides the Company with $65 million in additional liquidity through viable and adequate DIP and exit financing commitments.” Note that there's no mention there of recovery for the equity. “Company anticipates plan of reorganization support from at least 85% of secured debt holders and 80% of convertible note holders” Note that the equity doesn't even get mentioned there. “

As we went on, it's possible to think of this the other way around: “Think of this another way. $300 million and change of debt is going to get written off. OK, so that's a certain amount of pain for creditors, sure. In return they can ask for all the equity in the company. There's only a return to equity is the assets are worth more than the debts, which doesn't seem to be the case. So, why would the creditors allow old equity to capture some of the value when the creditors don't have to do that?”

QualTek stock price from NASDAQ OK, so we're gratified that our take on yesterday's (intraday) rise of 200% in QualTek was quickly reversed, as we said it would be. But theta is it that has people gambling on these Chapter 11 equities? 

The answer is that Hertz happened. Used car prices collapsed and that meant that Hertz was bust. Because they had bond issues financing the fleet, those bond issues requiring security against the value of the fleet. Falling car price meant the security was called, Hertz didn't have it, they're bust. But by the time that Hertz came out of Chapter 11 used car prices had soared. So, there was something left for the equity.

But this is extraordinarily unusual. Hertz is the exception. And yet people are gambling on every other Chapter 11 as if the same thing might happen. To which there are two possible answers. One is “No, it isn't”. The other is “OK, but what asset is going to reverse in value to make it happen?” Which, in pretty much every case, is going to provide the same answer as the first, “No”. 

Hey, betting on Chapter 11s could even be fun but only if everyone else is wrong at the same time.