Core Lithium (ASX: CXO) (OTCPK: CXOXF) should, on the standard measurements, be worth much more than it is. There's an obviously useful lithium mine there, they have the right to mine it, lithium mining is quite the little darling of the markets at present, so, well, why isn't Core worth more? It's this which explains why there's a substantial short position - 10% of the equity outstanding. Because there's the one large question we don't know the answer to. Effectively, who is going to gain the profits of a soaring lithium price?
Now it's true that lithium is less soaring than it was 6 months back, perhaps 40% down off its peaks. But for the standard spodumene miner (which is what Core intends to be) there's still a very significant gap between potential sales price and mining costs. But then comes the big question - who is going to gain that margin?
Core Lithium share price from ASXAs we can see the Core Lithium share price there has followed the China Spot lithium price reasonably closely. That seems reasonable, mining costs do not change as output prices change, therefore it is margin which does change. But there's a wrinkle in the mining of spodumene for lithium extraction. The 6% concentrate is sold to a processor. Well, OK. But the processor normally offers to aid in financing the mine in return for a guaranteed (called “offtake”) contract to the production. That's also all OK.
But as is explained here about Core Lithium, those contracts normally come with a cap and a collar. That is, a maximum price for the concentrate and a minimum one. What those caps and collar are largely depends upon when the contract was signed and the investment - or the commitment to it - was made. As far as we can tell the Core Lithium offtake contract was made when lithium prices were very low. A supposition that is possible therefore is that the cap on lithium concentrate prices is, compared to current market prices, low.
Now this is all inference and quite possibly incorrect at that. But as far as it's possible to see the financial terms of that contract are not public. So it really could be that Core Lithium has an entirely lovely lithium mine, a built in profit on production - but misses out on the soaring lithium price because of the cap on prices in that offtake contract. Which would be a pity, obviously, but would explain why there's that very large 10% of equity short position against Core Lithium.