On December 16, they raise the national flag of Bangladesh high upon their rooftops or display it outwards from their windows, to celebrate the Bangladesh Liberation War victory of 1971. For Pahela Baisakh, these juveniles adorn themselves in red and white attires and accessories, and relish the bowl of panta-illish. When the Rana plaza collapsed in April this year, they rushed with whatever they had to help the victims in Savar. In many respects, there is nothing exceptional about these Bangladeshis.
So, what makes them different?
They are the youths inside the “Bihari Camp,” a zone meant solely for a group of Urdu-speaking people labelled as “Stranded Pakistanis.”
Kanij Fatema, 21, a student of Accounting at Mohammadpur Kendriya College and a resident of Town Hall Bihari camp, says: “Those who were born long after independence like me love our country, Bangladesh. We are studying here and want to work here. But still people have a hard time trusting us. Whenever they find out the word ‘camp’ written as our address in any official documents, they neglect us.”
In pre-independence British India, there was an Urdu-speaking Muslim minority in the Hindu majority state of Bihar. In 1947, at the time of partition, the Bihari Muslims, many of whom were fleeing the violence that took place during partition, fled to East Pakistan.
After Bangladesh was born, in 1973, a survey was done on this community which produced two lists: one of those who wanted to stay in Bangladesh; and the other those who wanted to go to Pakistan.
The tent city takes root
“Before Bangladesh was born this [the land where Geneva camp is currently situated] was a vast open field,” recalls Md Iqbal Hossain, organising secretary of Stranded Pakistanis’ General Repatriation Committee (SPGRC), “In 1972, United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees and Red Cross came up with the scheme to repatriate the Biharis to Pakistan. They set up some makeshift tents here to accommodate the refugees. They set up a total of 70 camps, all made up of makeshift tents, in 13 districts across the country that accommodated 623,000 refugees. The relief work continued in these camps. The Urdu speaking Biharis who were residing in different colonies around the area from Zakir Hossain Road to Mirpur 1, came here to take shelter.”
However, despite efforts by the Bangladesh government to repatriate people to Pakistan, diplomatic negotiations stalled and over time it became clear that very few of the “Stranded Pakistanis” would be able to go to Pakistan.
“When the war of 1971 took place, it happened for a cause. To gain the right to speak in mother tongue and that is how Bangladesh was born. Now, we are born and being raised here and we have accepted the fact that we are Bangladeshis,” says Fatema..
Mehnaz Akhter Shyama, 19, another Town Hall camp resident, has just been admitted to BBA in Bangladesh University. She says: “I was raised here since birth. Why would I go over there? Moreover, that is a risky country to live nowadays. However, may be my mother would like to go there as many of our ancestors still have little inclination towards Pakistan. But we, the younger generation have no fascination about it. We have our future here and may be thinking about our future, our ancestors would also leave the thought of going back to Pakistan.”
Camp stigma
A serious allegation that comes from the youths inside the camps is that they highly suffer in finding suitable jobs, not because of a lack of qualifications, but because of the word “Camp.”
“I am pursuing BBA. One day I would like to work in a bank or in a reputed company. But the employers hesitate in recruiting us. For that many end up in jobs that are way below their. Like job of a receptionist or a teacher at any local kindergarten,” says Fatema.
Md Aftab Alam, 22, student of Northern University and resident of the same camp, says he went for an interview for a part-time job at a renowned retail outlet in the capital. However, immediately after realising he belongs to the so-called ‘Bihari’ community, the interviewer showed him the way out of the room.
“May be I at least got the call because I mentioned my address as ‘Zakir Hossain Road, Mohammadpur’ not ‘Town Hall Bihari camp’,” says Aftab.
Both Fatema and Aftab claim the word ‘camp’ is like a blemish on their identity for running day-to-day activities smoothly. For any official purpose they put the address of any ‘Bangali’ friend or neighbour living near the camp.
Rani, 14, Tarannum, 16 and Morjina, 18, three cousin sisters in Geneva camp, have not studied beyond class four or five. They now spend their time watching daily soaps on television and doing needle work. They said different NGOs (Non-government organisations) had come to the camp and provided short trainings on sewing and knitting to the young girls. They had learnt a few of them. Now they sometimes get orders from the NGOs to do embroideries on ladies wear. For each piece of cloth they get Tk150 to Tk400.
Overcrowded and unsupported
The bigger problem for most “Biharis”, however, lies not only in getting a job, but also in terms of availing the simplest facility that any citizen of the country is entitled to.
Md Iqbal Hossain says: “Until 1979, Bangladeshi government and the NGOs were able to send some 169,000 people to Pakistan. However, by the end of 70s, the process stopped. In 1977, late Nasim Khan founded the SPGRC and started constructing semi-pucca tin shed houses replacing the tents. In 1980, the whole camp was torched by fire. Then three NGOs - Rabita al-alam al-islami, Al Falah and Heed International – came forward and established semi-pucca houses for the stranded people.”
“Today you can see the dilapidated condition of the camps. Eventually when we found no light at the end of the tunnel, we started to reconstruct the houses by ourselves with our little savings and income. This huge camp was built without any concrete design or plan. No engineer or patronisation from the government was involved. As a result, it is a very unplanned and vulnerable one,” he adds.
“Do you see the unhygienic environment around?,” says Md Serajul Islam Rubel, 22, who runs a small shop inside Mohammadpur Geneva Camp selling paper packets and bulbs, “There is no proper arrangement of sanitation, let alone privacy inside this camp whereas the population is growing rapidly.”
“If our younger brothers go to the nearby field to play in the evening, they won’t be allowed in. The teams that come to play there would say, ‘you are stranded Pakistanis, why have you come here?’ After working or studying the whole day, the young people can’t even get a proper bathroom or go play in the field,” he adds.
When asked about his identity, he says: “We consider ourselves as Bangali, but unfortunately the Bangalis consider us as Biharis.”
You are what you speak
MD Sadeq, 18, studied in the Kaderia Madrasa nearby the camp up to class eight. He says: “We faced huge problems while getting admission in the madrasa. They said they would not admit any child from the camp. They said ‘you speak Urdu, you live inside the camp, what will you do by studying?’”.
Sadeq says after repeated pleas, they admitted him. “But the discrimination never stopped inside the classroom,” he adds.
Shamima Khatun, (not her real name) an HSC candidate from Lalmatia School and College, also faces problems at school due to her place of residence: “I never disclose my address to my classmates. Because if their parents find out that I live in the camp, they would prohibit their daughters to mingle with me. They have a mindset that the young boys and girls inside the Bihari camps are spoiled.”
Regarding the corrupt image of youths inside the camps, 55-year-old Md Hasan, the father of three youngsters who all live in the Geneva camp, says: “How can you expect a young adult to stay within the cultural and social norms when he does not study, or have any option for healthy entertainment? Moreover, due to dropping out from school and getting in work, they start earning money at a very early age. As a result, they get involved in unsocial activities liking gambling and taking drugs.”
“Now let’s get into the root of it. Outside the camp they are being constantly discriminated. As a result they keep coming back inside the camp and due to peer pressure get into such activities. Parents marry off their daughters early to keep them away from unethical practices,” laments Hasan.
He says: “My mother brought me to the camp when I was very small. Now my oldest son is 22. Still I continue to see my children being discriminated against in almost every field. Be it admission, getting jobs, making passport or simply playing at the nearby field.”
Rights returned, but problems remain
In 2008, following a writ petition, the high court of Bangladesh issued a verdict to reinstate citizen status and voting rights for the whole “Bihari” community.
Five years later, when asked what they wanted from the government, a number of youths from the Town Hall camp arrive at the same point. They say: “What was the point of providing us a national identity card, if we cannot avail facilities like any other citizen?”
“During the national and local elections, this community plays a role in electing representatives,” say a number of them, “So we have to ask why our situation is still so dire. We want to stay here and work for the country. We can emerge as a potential manpower of the country. Discriminating us may result into loss for the government.”
“If we cannot get a good job or education because of our address, then how would we be able to go outside the camp and make a better living?” they explain.
Md Iqbal Hossain also sees little change despite the change in the status of his community: “According to the verdict of HC in 2008, we are now Bangladeshis. Still the Ministry of Disaster Management and Relief bears the burden of paying millions of money as charges for water and electricity supply in these cramped camps for 2,500,000 people.”
“We would request the government to make some permanent arrangement for our rehabilitation. There are still many unused lands in the country. If they give us those lands in lease at the fixed government rate, then burden for both sides could be lessened. We can pay the rates in instalments,” says Iqbal.
“The Urdu-speaking people who reside outside the camps are not stigmatised. So if we could live outside these camps, our young generation would not be discriminated against anymore just because the tag of ‘camp’,” he says.
For the “Biharis”, that change cannot come soon enough.