WB asks Tk4 crore in refund

The World Bank has asked the Health Ministry to return Tk4 crore of allotted funds, after finding evidence of irregularities in procurement practices and financial management activities at three operation plans under the ministry.

A special review by the bank raised allegations against former line directors of National Nutrition Services (NNS) Dr Eklasur Rahman, Dr Khondokar Md Sifayetullah of Non Communicable Diseases (NCD) and incumbent line director Dr Be-Nazir Ahmed of Communicable Diseases Control (CDC). The three operation plans have been running under the Health Population Nutrition Sector Development Programme (HPNSDP) of the Health Ministry.

World Bank Country Director Johannes Zutt wrote a letter on this regard to Mohammad Mejbahuddin, secretary of the Economic Relations Divisions (ERD), on April 30; while the ERD then issued a letter to the health secretary on May 6 directing the ministry to return more than $500,000 to the global lender and inform the ERD about this by May 31.

Source said the funds have not reportedly been returned so far.

Health Secretary MM Niazuddin, however, told the Dhaka Tribune that the ministry had already settled the problem and collected the refunded money; but added that he did not know whether all of the money had been returned.

On the other hand, an incumbent line director of one the three operation plans, seeking anonymity, said they  received information about the World Bank’s directive to return the funds only a couple of days ago.

Sources said observations about questionable programme expenditures by the operation plans were mentioned in an audit report by the Foreign Aided Project Audit Directorate in 2012.

Based on those findings, the International Development Association (IDA) of the World Bank carried out a special financial management review last year, finding strong indication of inappropriate procurement practices and fraudulent activities in the performance of procurement and financial management activities.

Inappropriate procurement practices were identified at the NNS including procurement of items through the request for quotation method and beyond the scope of the procurement plan approved by the World Bank in November 2011. Packages were also reportedly split to avoid competitive procedures, while bids had similar handwritten dates, spelling mistakes, fonts, styles and descriptions, bid prices were in arithmetical sequence and there was similar handwriting on the document of the procuring entity and the vendors’ document.

The IDA review also found that honorarium were paid to line directors for several training programmes which they never attended, as well finding evidence of forged signatures in the list of training participants who were said to have been given honorarium.

The combined amount of these fraudulent honorarium practices amounted to around Tk95 lakh, while total amount of malpractices in the three line directorates was around Tk11 crore.

After receiving the IDA review report, the Health Ministry took departmental actions against the line directors concerned and managed to recover some funds that were misappropriated through payment of honorariums. 

Asked about the allegations, Dr Eklasur Rahman, former line director of the NNS, admitted that there could have been procedural mistakes, but claimed that no money was misappropriated. He added that the NNS received instalment of the funds in April 2012 and were forced to go for spot quotation instead of open tender – which was a four-month-long process – as the fiscal year ended in June.

Dr Be-Nazir Ahmed, director of the CDC, told the Dhaka Tribune there were audit objection of Tk31 lakhs against the CDC. Because of delayed release of fund, the operation plan had to go for procurement on spot quotation and by voucher, he said, claiming that it was a negotiable audit objection.

Both of them, however, claimed that they did not receive any letter from the World Bank or any other authorities.

Despite repeated attempts to get comments, former NCD line director Dr Khondokar Md Sifayetullah, who was also the ex-DG of the health directorate, did not receive any phone call.

Dr Rashid-e-Mahbub, president of Health Rights Movement Bangladesh and also an ex-president of Bangladesh Medical Association (BMA), said most line directors were political appointees who lacked the required qualification and stayed busy with misappropriating money. He also recommended that the operation plans be run on contract basis and monitored by senior health officials.