The Salk/Ohsu team also found that its gene correction did not cause any detectable mutations in other parts of the genome - a major concern for gene editing. Still, the technology was not 100% successful. It increased the number of repaired embryos from 50%, which would have occurred naturally, to 74%. The embryos, tested in the laboratory, were allowed to develop for only a few days. "There is still much to be done to establish the safety of the methods, therefore they should not be adopted clinically," Robin Lovell-Badge, a professor at London's Francis Crick Institute who was not involved in the study, said in a statement.The big @nature paper behind the headlines today: #CRISPR editing human #embryos for pathogenic mutation correction https://t.co/X8QIUVke9I pic.twitter.com/bnBjqHsyBT
— Shabana Khan? (@DrShabanaKhan) August 2, 2017
'Utmost caution'
Washington's National Academy of Sciences (Nas) earlier this year softened its previous opposition to the use of gene editing technology in human embryos, which has raised concerns it could be used to create so-called designer babies. There is also a fear of introducing unintended mutations into germline cells. "No one is thinking about this because it is practically impossible at this point," Izpisua Belmonte said. "This is still very basic research ... let alone something as complex as what nature has done for millions and millions of years of evolution."Great news for the #mankind: Human #embryos edited to stop disease https://t.co/iULbBjcnf0— Gulrez Sheikh (@drsheikhRSS) August 2, 2017An international group of 11 organisations, including the American Society of Human Genetics and Britain's Wellcome Trust, on Wednesday issued a policy statement recommending against genome editing that culminates in human implantation and pregnancy, while supporting publicly funded research into its potential clinical applications. Salk's Izpisua Belmonte, emphasising that much more study is needed, said the most important practical application for the new technology could be in correcting genetic mutations in babies either in utero or right after they are born. "It is crucial that we continue to proceed with the utmost caution, paying the highest attention to ethical considerations," he said.