Dialogues on decency
Publish : 29 Sep 2016, 21:08
Recently, a mother made waves on the Internet by writing a blog on how her ex-husband had randomly knocked her to express concerns about their daughter posting pictures on Facebook wearing 'inappropriate clothing'. Using the typical excuse of 'what will people say?', the concerned father cited friends and family who had all commented on the indecency. While prolonged discussions on the clothing of women, young or old, is a norm in most places, the welcome change in this case was the mother's impassioned defense of her daughter. Throughout the blog, she asks people to consider the traits that actually make a human being who they are – their compassion, kindness and strength, among other things – and asks a valid question that all young girls who have received such criticism in their lifetimes have been burning to ask: “what sort of adult uses their valuable time to stalk young girls and judge their character based on their clothes?”Policing girls' bodiesPolicing what girls wear is an age-old tradition in our society. Many parents will do it out of very real worries of their children's safety, because we know all too well the harassment that women continue to face in public places in our country. All you need is one slip of the orna and there will be countless roadside Romeos, young and old, willing to comment on your appearance, press up against your body using the crowds on the road as an excuse, and much, much worse. However, as has been proven time and again, a culture of impunity means women will continue to be assaulted regardless of what they wear.
And while physical assault is a constant terror for girls in our country, the psychological assault of others constantly debating your morality using your body as their battle ground is one that we gloss over all too often. Starting from inquisitive neighbours to overly-concerned family members, everyone has an opinion on what is 'decent'. In some places it will be that kameez that is a bit too low-cut or that pair of jeans that is a bit too tight. In others, even a traditional sari can be considered vulgar, or that bit of hair sticking out from under your scarf might mean you're not the good girl you pretend to be. And in too many families, instead of worrying about raising strong, confident and compassionate daughters, too many parents will worry about what people think of how their daughters dress, who they talk to and how their actions reflect upon the families' good names in society.Taboos are not traditionsHowever, more and more guardians are now starting to question these social norms of 'decency', and calling out those who feel the need to map out the honour of a family on the articles of clothing of its female members. In a video that went viral recently, Bollywood acting legend Amitabh Bacchan read out a touching letter to his young granddaughters, asking them to live their lives the way they want to, and not the way others envisage it for them. As he succintly puts it, “don't ever let anyone tell you that the length of your skirt is a measure of your character.”
Given that it is usually the older generation who decide on the taboos and so-called traditions that police what women wear, this video going viral is a welcome change that hopefully shows a shift in how the 'elders' think. In our culture, it can often be very difficult to disagree with the older generation, simply because we are meant to always show respect to our elders. And often it is even more difficult to disagree when age-old traditions that go back centuries are cited as the reason for opposing greater freedom in women's choices and lifestyles. But while there are countless beautiful traditions that are a part of our culture and will always be, the varying levels of the tradition of purdah is something that feminists in Bengal have campaigned against for ages, and is one that we simply must let go of.Bodies, not markers of moralityBut why make such a fuss over clothing, when there are so many battles to be fought on behalf of women? Because you might not realise it, but something as simple as waking up, wearing whatever you want and walking out the door is something that most girls have to think twice about, regardless of their social status. Because all too often, they let so many regular, everyday decisions be influenced and controlled by what others will say that it becomes a habit to not dress how they want to, behave how they want to and say what they want to.
Every time you ask your daughters to dress according to others' definitions of what is decent, you chip away at their free will, and you tell them what's outside is more important than what is inside. Every time you ask them 'what will people say?', you tell them that their voices are not important, and you, instead of loving her, end up silencing her. And in doing so, you contribute to a culture of shame that teaches girls that if they are being insulted, stalked or even abused, it's their fault for not conforming to society's standards of morality, and they have no right to stand up against its judgment.