Transparency is still lacking in the stock markets as existing trading and financial disclosures by listed companies are insufficient to gauge the market pulse properly, analysts say.
Compared to the disclosure presentation mode being practised by the stock exchanges in the region –Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE), Karachi Stock Exchange (KSE) and Colombo Stock Exchange (CSE) – the country’s two stock exchanges lag behind them in most cases.
For example, the company disclosures and price sensitive information have been posted on the Colombo Stock Exchange websites by scanning original copies from the companies. This practice is absent in local stock markets.
Shariful Islam, a retail investor, said actually most investors in our market invest without analysing the company fundamentals. “Detailed disclosures – positive or negative – should be disclosed in more specific way, which will make us aware.”
The local stock exchanges should pick up best practices of other countries for the greater interest of investors and market as well, he said.
Breakdowns of trading volume and even script-wise investments by fund managers, institutional investors and foreign investors are displayed on the screen on a daily basis at the KSE and BSE. Those data can easily be analysed to gauge what most sophisticated and relatively rational investors are thinking about the market, which can help the retailer measure market direction.
These are the obvious examples of how to make the stock market more transparent and accountable. It is unclear whether any investors were truly able to take advantage of the timing of the earnings release and other disclosures.
“The market lacks transparency in some ways,” said Wali-ul-Maroof Matin, an analyst and ex-chief executive officer of thr Chittagong Stock exchange.
He said transparency in revelation has been a grey area due to lack of adequate regulations and proper monitoring. “We need to come out of the odds because peoples’ involvement is increasingly growing.”
He said: “Investors want transparent and clear disclosure about present and future corporate operations and performance. Disclosures should include the most relevant information in a format that investors can understand.”
The country’s two stock exchanges – Dhaka Stock Exchange and Chittagong Stock Exchange – needto improve the information revelation mode for presenting information in more transparent and specific way.
Mahmood Osman Imam, a professor at the University of Dhaka, said stock exchanges should disclose details as far as it can for bringing more transparency and accountability in the market.
The disclosures will include details that are required to create a correct picture of the companies’ true financial situations and opportunities, he said.
“Still, there is enough room for a lot of improvementsin the mode of disclosures,” said Yawer Sayeed, a fund manager.
He said revealing more information means more transparent and useful information for the investors. "However, there is no end of excellence in presenting the revelations.”
Admitting the fact of lacking existing disclosure system, DSE President Ahsanul Islam Titu said: “We’re working on it. DSE will post original copies of the company announcements. So the investors can read it as it is.”
Chittagong Stock Exchange President Al Maruf Khan said breakdown of investment volume of institutional, foreign and mutual funds can be seen soon as CSE is making its efforts over the last eight months in this connection.
He said there are some legal barriers to disclose information of the company in some cases.
An analyst preferring not to be named said: “At a time when there continues to be a growing global demand for increased transparency and disclosure, the disclosure system of local stock exchanges is unfortunately being emasculated because of benign neglect.”
The listed companies are (at present) publishing quarterly financial statements in the website of the bourses in a very concise form, without showing details of some vital components of financial statements, such as detailed sources of income, he said.
He said institutional investors are assumed to take rational investment decision. “So the international practice of disclosing the buy and sell amount of market turnover by foreign investors, local institutional investors and mutual funds can help retail investors to know the market direction. If our neighboring exchanges can disclose it, we should follow the same practices.”
This information, he observed, are crucial for investors to make knowledgeable investment decisions.