Most of the country’s RMG trade unions are reportedly controlled by workers’ federations affiliated with US-based non-profit organisation Solidarity Centre, with many labour leaders and factory owners raising concerns that the sector might become a hostage to a vested quarter.
According to the Labour Ministry, 152 trade unions have registered following last year’s Rana Plaza disaster. There are allegations that 142 of those unions were linked with nine federations “affiliated” with the Solidarity Centre.
Sources said around 20 leaders of those RMG workers federations were controlling the entire sector.
“We have recently got involved with the Solidarity Centre and the organisation is now paying monthly Tk13,000 each to two organisers of my federation,” said Md Kamrul Hasan, general secretary of Akota Garments Workers Federation that secured 12 trade union registrations this year.
Several leaders of the nine RMG workers federations also admitted to the Dhaka Tribune that they received “financial and technical” support from the Solidarity Centre.
Amirul Haque Amin, president of National Garment Workers Federation, told the Dhaka Tribune that his federation was affiliated with Solidarity Centre and received technical support from them.
However, Jennifer Kuhlman, field programme specialist at Solidarity Centre’s Bangladesh office, denied allegations of having affiliates with any RMG workers federation in Bangladesh. Replying to a query, she told the Dhaka Tribune through an e-mail that the centre only provided “technical” assistance for building the capacity of federations and factory-level unions.
As per existing regulations, the aspirant candidate of the workers should deal with the Joint Directorate of Labour for registration, but in most cases it was the federations that were involved with the registration process.
Leaders from several trade unions told the Dhaka Tribune that authorities concerned were providing registration to only the applicants who were affiliated with international NGOs or rights groups, while others who fulfilled all conditions were being denied registration.
“I have applied to the Joint Directorate of Labour for two unions, but they did not get registered despite having the required documents,” said Montu Ghosh, president of Garment Workers’ Trade Union Centre.
Montu, however, added that to the best of his knowledge, unions that were affiliated with foreign organisations were getting licences in large volume, creating the possibility that the control of the sector might be left to a certain group.
“They [federations affiliated with NGOs or foreign unions] are getting licence for many trade unions as they have both power and money because of connection with the NGOs and international lobby,” said Bahrain Sultan Bahar, president of Jago Bangladesh Garments Sramik, a workers’ federation.
However, denying the allegations, SM Ashrafuzzaman, director of Department of Labour, told the Dhaka Tribune: “We provide registration through due process and in compliance with regulations, and there is no connection of any influential group in providing registrations.”
The unions that did not get registration were denied approval because they did not have the required number of workers, he added.
On the other hand, apparel makers also expressed concerns that the sector’s future might be dominated by a vested quarter.
“It is dangerous if most of the trade unions are under the control of a vested quarter. The whole sector would be hostage to them and they can create anarchy at any time in the sector,” Reaz Bin Mahmood, vice president of the BGMEA, told the Dhaka Tribune.
We want trade unions with the “real” presentation of “real” workers, said Reaz, adding that only some of the unions had genuine workers as members, while others were made of fake ones.
Factory owners, preferring to stay unnamed, claimed that if “puppet” federations could form trade unions, they could also take control of the RMG sector and use it as a tool to deal with issues like the GSP.
The intention of Solidarity Centre was not clear as they were only focusing on the RMG sector, the factory owners added.
“Connection with the foreign unions or rights group are very threatening for the sector, as we have seen some misleading information being provided to the US government without the knowledge of Bangladeshi government,” said a factory owner, seeking anonymity.
Based on those “misleading information,” the US urged the Bangladesh government to take action against 19 factory owners, he added.
However, the Commerce Ministry later claimed that it did not find any truth to the allegations raised against those 19 factories.
Factory owners claimed that those who were applying for trade union registration did not have basic knowledge about labour rights and responsibilities, and were being manipulated by a vested quarter as a result.
The issue of freedom of association and collective bargaining came under spotlight after the collapse of Rana Plaza last year, which claimed the lives of at least 1,136 and wounded thousands more. On June 27 last year, the US government suspended the GSP facility for Bangladesh, mentioning the lack of workers’ rights and poor working conditions in the country’s RMG sector.