Budget beyond reality: CPD

Under the present economic and political context, the implementation of the proposed budget is unrealistic, said the Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD) on Friday.

The revenue income plan was the weakest link in the budgetary framework, as the budget lacked a harmonisation between revenue income and expenditure, said the CPD.

“The budget is very big in black and white but its implementation will fall far behind the expectation. Because this is the election year,” said Debapriya Bhattacharya, a CPD distinguished fellow.

The leading think-tank gave its reaction to the budget proposed by Finance Minister AMA Muhith at a press briefing on an analysis of the national budget for FY2013-14 in the city.

Debapriya was sceptical about the revenue income target of Tk1.67tn in the proposed budget.

“The weakest thing in the budget is that the finance minister has been trying to make up expenditure with specific income, which is at odds with reality,” he said.

Revenue (19.9%) was projected to grow faster than public expenditure (17.5%). Total budget expenditure is set at 18.7% of GDP and revenue income will be 13.4% of GDP, which is the highest in the history of Bangladesh.

“This is full of elusive targets in the election year,” said the CPD distinguished fellow.

About budgetary allocation for the Padma bridge project, Debapriya said the faster the bridge is built, the earlier the country will be benefitted. “But the way the government is going to build the bridge will bring indiscipline in the economic system.” 

The issue of Padma Bridge financing and the generation of the required resources as well as its likely implications for fiscal-monetary management will remain a continuing distraction in FY2014, he said.

He slammed the government for keeping a provision in the budget for whitening illegally earned money.

He believes the opportunity benefits only some particular sectors. Only Tk380m was received as tax against the total whitened amount of Tk13bn during 2009-13. “Considering its political and social damage, the economy gets no benefit out of it,” he said.

Debapriya was also critical about the proposed budget that mentioned nothing about the Rana Plaza tragedy. “The proposed budget offered nothing for the welfare of the RMG workers.”

He, however, appreciated the move to widen tax-free income limits for senior citizens and women. “This is a good move to the reduce tax liability of marginal taxpayers.”

“The import duty has been imposed on some goods for encouraging local industry,” he said, “but the decrease in supplementary duty on SIM cards will put domestic firms under pressure.”

About the first ever district budget allotted for Tangail, he said: “I did not find it is a budget for districts in any way. This might just be called the government’s financial statement for Tangail district.”

CPD, in its budget analysis, expressed concerns over the persistent cut in allocations for the education and health sectors. It also flayed the budget for reducing prime beneficiaries of the social security sector.

The current political uncertainties are likely to continue till a compromise is reached as regards to holding parliamentary elections. “This will seriously undermine the possibility of taking advantage of the various proposals in the budget to stimulate investment in the economy.”

Bangladesh has not been able to attain more than 7% GDP growth in the past. Attaining the targeted growth of 7.2% will certainly hinge on raising investment to GDP ratio and lowering capital to output ratio, the CPD analysis said.

“Both of these will be a challenge and will call for a significant breakthrough in terms of resource generation, resource allocation, efficacy of resource use and efficacy of development administration,” it said.

“Will there be an appetite for all these in an election year?”

The performance of the Bangladesh economy is still predominantly dependent on stimulating domestic demand (about 85% of GDP). This will certainly hinge on the robust performance of domestic market oriented activities, which in turn will depend on stimulating domestic demand and investment, according to the CPD analysis.

The global economic recovery is expected to be slow in 2013 and 2014 with consequent adverse implications for outward-oriented investment during FY2014.

A major challenge will be mobilising the required $3.2bn foreign aid package to assist the deficit financing. The second challenge here will be ensuing that the development administration has the capacity to use this significantly larger resource, CPD said.

The increasing share of bank borrowing in deficit financing could crowd out private sector borrowing and is likely to further raise the interest burden in the economy, particularly at a time when non-performing loans afflict the banking system.

CPD Executive Director Mustafizur Rahman, among others, was present at the press conference.