BPC losing 'staggering' sums on state-to-state oil purchases

Annual losses of Bangladesh Petroleum Corporation have gone up nearly 10 times in about 10 years after it introduced the government-to-government negotiations to ensure energy security and prevent procurement delays.

BPC introduced the state level negotiation in 2003-04 fiscal year and it was enforced fully in 2005. Data shows losses of the state-owned organisation were much lower before, under the competitive market tender policy.

Under government-level contracts, the BPC closes minimum two-year deals with foreign government oil companies, reviewing the premium or transport, insurance and other costs of the deals every six months. According to BPC officials, such deals ensure regularity and security of supply with less procurement hassle.

However, the seemingly “reliable” mode of procurement has massively increased the state oil importer’s losses. In FY2011-12, the BPC faced the highest losses ever, Tk105.52bn for 5.18m tonnes of oil. When it procured oil under the competitive market tender policy in FY2003-04, it lost only Tk9.6bn on 3.52m tonnes.

BPC Chairman Md Eunusur Rahman claimed the losses were caused by buying oil on the international market at a high price and selling it locally at a low price.

However, local prices have been hiked a number of times to address rises on the international market.

BPC officials, requesting anonymity, said the rise in losses were due to multi-level commissions being added to oil prices and under-the-table deals between top BPC officials and agents of foreign state oil companies stationed in Bangladesh.

They said these agents receive benefits from the exporters if they can ensure that Bangladesh procures oil when market prices are high.

The agents also benefit by manipulating small rises in the premium, between 10 US cents and 50 US cents per tonne, which mounts up as the average order stands at 5m tonnes.  

Another source of loss is the deliberate delay in unloading at the ports, resulting in the BPC paying heavy demurrage to fuel carriers. It paid roughly $200m (Tk15,560m) between July and December 2012 alone.

The BPC chief claimed that the demurrage incurs because the storage facility is very small and only two months' supply of oil can be kept at a time. "But we are trying to increase capacity and store another month of oil."

Sources said in most cases the delays are intentional and staged by BPC officials to get “additional” benefits.” They claimed it normally takes a while for the payment of demurrage. To avoid long-term delay, agents provide “benefits” to concerned officials for speedy disbursement.  

However, the BPC chief claimed that they do not negotiate with agents and deal with foreign state oil companies directly.

Experts suggest the solution would be to scrap state-level negotiations and return to open market tenders. They argue that, as the government does not have experts to monitor the business and the BPC team clearly cannot rein in such surplus costs, the field is left open for interest groups to run the show.

However, energy division secretary, Md Mozammel Haque Khan, claimed, “I see no shortage of expert manpower, as government officials are capable enough to negotiate on the issue.”

Bangladesh University of Engineering and Technology (Buet) professor and energy expert Ijaz Hossain told the Dhaka Tribune: “$1 loss per tonne means a huge amount of money is being lost. The government should revert to procuring oil from the competitive market.”

He also said the government should explain why it continues to use this method of procurement, despite such losses. “We should be following the process which costs us less.”

The Buet expert did admit that competitive market procurement takes time but stressed that if it reduces BPC's losses, then that course should be re-adopted.

The BPC chief pointed out that in the official deals, they can obtain hard loans from the national oil companies, which is a great option considering the hassle the state oil importer faces opening letters of credit (LC) with local banks.

He cited a recent example where the Philippine National Oil Company will be providing $328m credit financing to BPC at 4.5% interest and a 150-day payment deferment clause to secure imports for the second half of 2013. The financing deal was approved by the Finance Ministry on May 8. A loan of $700m was also taken from Petrochina recently under the same conditions. 

However, an energy expert, preferring to be unnamed, claimed that such loans cannot be justified as a large amount of money is literally being handed to foreign state oil companies. He added that the loans also serve as an obligation to the exporters, something that would not be there in the competitive market policy.

The Consumers Association of Bangladesh (CAB) energy adviser Prof M Shamsul Alam told the Dhaka Tribune that with open market tenders, BPC would import oil from the lowest bidder.  Thanks to the competition, there was little scope for manipulating prices and for agents and officials to reap any personal benefit.

At present, instead of bidding, companies are charging high prices, which their local agents get approved from BPC and Energy Division through lobbying.

“G2G [government-to-government] negotiation was introduced in line with a government decision and the government will have to decide if the open tender process is to be brought back,” the energy division secretary said, adding that they have no such plans.

Member of parliamentary standing committee on energy ministry and an opposition BNP lawmaker Mahbub Uddin Khokon said the sector was at risk due to corruption in the government. He advocated the formation of a committee to identify weaknesses of the current oil procurement policy. He also called upon the Anti-Corruption Commission to investigate the current process. 

CAB adviser Shamsul said: “BPC has become a burden for the country. On one hand there is huge corruption and on the other, huge subsidy.”

He said an expert panel should be formed for full-scale reform of the sector. “We have to move out of the bureaucratic tangle and appoint experts to carry out the work.”