Experts: Mindless investment weighing on power sector

Unchecked and unrealistic infrastructural development is turning out to be a massive burden on the power sector, said experts, suggesting that it is high time the government looked into the matter and focused more on planned expansion and upgrade the sector’s mechanism.  

However, government officials including State Minister for Power Nasrul Hamid Bipu defended the massive expansion of the power sector, with a number of power plants on the card.

They were speaking an online discussion titled “Covid-19 - Power Sector in National Budget for FY2020-21: Allocative Priorities and Alternate Proposals” on Wednesday, organized by the Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD).

Buet’s Professor M Tamim, said the problems is properly investing in transmission and distribution right now because the Covid pandemic has shown us modernization of system is important.

"While we have power coming from nuclear, coal, LNG and even imported sources, we need to have the system operation working most effectively, in an automated and fully independent manner, to avoid major power disturbance," he insisted.

“Once we have best contract (under which the private sector projects are run), we can have the costs in the power sector under control. Between summer and winter, Bangladesh must have a power generation gap of at least 4,000MW since in the summer days power consumption goes up significantly, he said.

Exporting the additional electricity during winter can be considered, the energy expert suggested. 

Terming 10% power reserve capacity nothing big for the power sector, he said: “The reserved power can come handy when needed badly. However, reliable and efficient system will reduce dependency on power reserve.”  

He also went critical of the 2016 power sector masterplan, saying: “We must have to have realistic power demand forecast.

“If we cannot utilize the growing investment in power sector, that will weigh heavily on the economy,” he stated. 

The energy expert demanded that the Bangladesh Energy Regulatory Commission (Amendment) Bill, 2020, which allows manifold revision of power and gas prices, must mention how many times the tariffs can be revised. 

“Otherwise, it will lead to a burden among the masses,” Tamim feared, suggesting to grow the spread of renewable energy.

Former Power Division secretary Fouzul Kabir Khan said the government needs to fix a proper growth since power generation is correlated to that. 

“If you don’t have a proper forecast of GDP growth, you’ll always have an over ambitious power demand,” he feared. 

At the same time, having excessive capacity in power generation is not always a good idea since it involves a lot of expenditure, Fouzul said.

Claiming that the entire power generation capacity is never utilized in Bangladesh, he said: “The IPPs (independent power plant) receive a large amount of capacity payment. Even the idle government-run plants get compensation.”

He went on saying the Speedy Supply of Power and Energy (Special Provision) Act 2010 helped gain the capacity, but turned out to a reason for the power sector’s inefficiency.

“The law has been renewed many times and is not longer necessary. So, it needs to be revoked,” he opined. 

The former bureaucrat said the latest bill allowing multiple revision of power prices will prove wrong.

“The electricity tariff in Bangladesh is no longer lower than that in its neighbouring countries. So, resorting to tariff hike instead of improving efficiency, to make up Tk8,000 deficit is not right,” he observed.  

CPD Chairman Rehman Sobhan said what we did not put on the table was the assumption on the forecasting of the power demand. 

"What are the central assumptions that were made about demands forecasting? Obviously it was related to growth and we’re deriving certain coefficients relating to GDP growth and then computing power demand from there," said the eminent economist.

"So it would be useful to see what, in fact, have been the deviations from the GDP growth assumptions and the demand for power as my suspicion is we can make a reverse demand that in fact if there were accurate projections, then the consumption of power may suggest the GDP itself may not be as robust as the public figures actually indicate. And this would be concretely derived from the under-consumption of power in relation to forecasting. So this would an interesting exercise for both Power Division and the CPD to work out."

He also questioned the operation of rental power plants despite them being expensive. 

Lauding the massive expansion of power capacity during the Awami League regimes, the economist, however, said over capacity in the infrastructure sector does not reflect his thoughts. 

"We can take some lessons from Chinese that are where you have supply, you should then be going out your way to create demand. This should not even be made the important selling point when we are attracting FDI and even domestic investments.

We should be then trying to tie up generation of power from particular plants to particular investment zones in the country. 

In fact, in one of the ways in which you are marketing the zone is that you will be giving guaranteed power supply to the investors. And it will be an important selling point for foreign investment for any country," he continued.

From that sense, I think the government did not consciously generate and market the demand. 

Talking of the IPPs, he said: “The IPP projects have been very successful, but have we, in fact, given them a complete win-win situation in which you guarantee them a rate of return irrespective of the level of capacity utilization which goes on? 

So all the risk is then assumed by the government and the IPPs are then at least given a guaranteed rate of their best part.

State minister Nasrul said the government formulated a master plan for the power sector back in 2010 which has been reviewed several times later on considering the country’s growth till 2041. And the power demand was forecast based on that.

Since the energy sector scenario, mechanism and the users’ behavior are changing, the plans are being updated accordingly, which is quite normal for any country, he said.

“Japan has already invested $6 billion in the power sector and may invest $2 billion. It is doing so envisioning the future prospect of investing in Bangladesh,” he said.

Following the forecast by experts, we projected demand for power. Also, 108 economic zones are planned. If the one in Mirsarai started operations by now, we could have failed to meet its demand, he said. 

Giving credit to the prime minster for allowing private sector investment for setting up power plants which ultimately led to the massive capacity, he said they are now mulling of exporting electricity. 

Bangladesh’s power generation capacity 23,436MW, which was nearly 5,000MW, including captive power, in 2009.

“But the power sector actually has some 16,000 MW in hand,” he claimed. 

During summer, the average peak load hovers between 12,000MW and 14,000MW.

But in the winter, the demand stays around 7,000-7,500MW, clearly depicting that a massive amount of the installed capacity remain unused during that season, from mid-November to early February.

On May 29 this year, BPDB had registered a whopping 12,893MW production, the highest ever in the country’s history.

The government also plans to take the installed power generation capacity to 24,000MW by 2021.

CPD’s Khondaker Golam Moazzem presented a keynote paper at the event, where he mentioned overcapacity is a growing concern for the power sector which has further aggravated during the Covid-19 period.