‘Unplanned stimulus delivery to increase inequality, instability’

An implementation of stimulus packages without a well-thought-out plan will lead to an increase in inequality, poverty and political instability amid the coronavirus pandemic, economists and experts said on Tuesday.

The stimulus packages should be implemented with efficiency, they recommended. 

They were speaking at a virtual dialogue on the theme, “Responding to Covid-19: A Rapid Assessment of Stimulus Packages and Relief Measures.”  

The Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD) organized the virtual dialogue, with CPD executive director Dr. Fahmida Khatun moderating the discussion. She said the implementation of stimulus packages without a well-thought-out plan would increase inequality and instability. 

The executive director of the Policy Research Institute of Bangladesh, Ahsan Habib Mansur, suggested that a multi-stakeholder task force, consisting of representatives from the government, central bank, commercial banks, international development partners, civil society, non-government organizations and academia be formed to monitor the delivery of the Covid-19 liquidity support packages and evaluating their effectiveness. 

Loan defaulters should not be allowed access to any of the COVID-19 related liquidity support packages, he urged the government.

Ahsan Habib Mansur said banks should disburse SME loans as soon as possible because 70% people had become unemployed in the SME sector due to the economic ramifications of the virus.

Presenting a research paper at the dialogue, CPD research director Dr Khondaker Golam Moazzem said the amount of defaulted loans would increase if the banks did not evaluate credit risks in implementing stimulus packages. 

He said banks would be highly unlikely to disburse loans to new small entrepreneurs because the disbursed loans to new SME clients during FY2019 accounted for 10% of their   total loans.

Mutual Trust Bank Managing Director and CEO Syed Mahbubur Rahman said the country’s banking sector had not been in good shape for the last several years. Now, the implementation of stimulus packages had put extra pressure on the banks, he added.

The interest rate of all loan products was now at 9%, while the cost of funds of banks was almost 11%.

“We could not transfer Tk16,000 crore to the banks’ profit account as the central bank  had suspended the interest from borrowers for two months,” he added. 

Syed Mahbubur Rahman, however, said the central bank had taken several monetary policy measures to boost liquidity in the money market.

Bangladesh Bank executive director Lila Rashid said the central bank had six teams to monitor the implementation of the stimulus packages. Besides, the Finance Ministry had formed a national monitoring team to supervise and evaluate the effectiveness of stimulus packages announced by Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina, she added.

The central bank was working on drafting credit guarantee scheme guidelines to implement the stimulus packages, she added.

Former BKMEA president and Plummy Fashions managing director Md Fazlul Hoque; National Association of Small and Cottage Industries of Bangladesh (NASCIB) Central Executive Committee president Mirza Nurul Ghani Shovon and IndustriALL Bangladesh Council (IBC) General Secretary China Rahman attended the dialogue, among others.

CPD recommendations to implement stimulus packages 

The allocation for funding healthcare should be increased in the budget, and enough liquidity support at low interest rates should be made available for building hospitals.

Loan defaulters should not be allowed to access any of the Covid--19 related liquidity support packages, while  transparency and accountability mechanisms should be in place for all Covid-19 related liquidity support packages, the dialogue recommended.

Furthermore, the think tank in its recommendations said a multi-stakeholder taskforce should be formed for monitoring the delivery of the Covid-19 liquidity support packages and evaluating their effectiveness. The  central bank should introduce a credit guarantee scheme for enterprises, it further recommended.