US and India at loggerheads over agriculture issue

India has not moved an inch from its stance to subsidise food procurement for distribution among poor people, throwing negotiation on the Bali package, which was progressing yesterday, into a delicate phase.

Minister of Commerce and Industry Anand Sharma made it clear at a press conference on the sidelines of the ninth WTO Ministerial Conference in Bali yesterday as he explained why India wants continuing with the agriculture subsidy.

“It has to be a fair and balanced agreement,” he said, stressing the need for ensuring food security of the poor not only of India, but also the vast majority of the world. “It’s better to have no agreement than to have a bad agreement.”

An official of Bangladesh delegation told the Dhaka Tribune that India wants to continue with the agriculture subsidy at 10% of total agriculture output on a permanent basis, but some other countries, particularly the USA, want to make it permanent after four years.

As per the existing WTO rules, a member cannot spend more than 10% of agriculture subsidy.

India’s firm stance on the issue might also influence those countries to stick to their demand, making the fate of the whole package of negotiation vulnerable, said the official from Bangladesh.

Bangladesh expected a deal to be adopted at the ministerial meeting as Commerce Secretary Mahbub Ahmed presented the Bangladesh position at the plenary session yesterday.

It’s not that an agreement on a single issue is possible, rather they are linked with each other and has to be agreed on the whole package, WTO Director General Roberto Azevedo said earlier.

The negotiation on agriculture subsidy has so far been the lone issue to have made the deal uncertain a concern with which the four-day conference began on Tuesday.

“We’ve not come here to collapse any meeting. India is committed to a positive outcome in Bali,” Anand said, amid apprehensions over a possible setback in the negotiation. “India is committed but also to a balanced and fair outcome.”

He explained India wants to feed its 820m people at subsidised rate 5kg of food grains per person a month at Rs1-3 per Kg to comply with its Food Security Act.

The country considered the proposed agreement on subsidy under negotiation on agriculture issue, one of the three main pillars of the package, is an outdated one.

Because the calculation of agriculture subsidy is based on external reference prices of 1986-88, despite global food prices have increased manifold during this period.

The G-33, grouping of 46-member developing nations including India, China and Indonesia, has proposed to amend the WTO Agreement on Agriculture (AoA) to procure foodgrains from poor farmers at minimum support price and sell to poor people at cheap rates through public distribution system.

The G-33 proposal on food security is aimed at addressing the problems faced by developing countries due to outdated WTO rules.

“I would like to make this absolutely clear that we have not come here as petitioners to beg for a Peace Clause restrained from what that it is binding on us to accept 1986-88 prices and make ourselves vulnerable to disputes and calculations, the answer is firm no,” he said, in response to a question whether India has any room to stay back from its stance for a compromise.