No more secrets - Swiss banks learn to shape up, not shut up

Switzerland’s allure as a place to stash cash has been badly damaged by a US-led campaign against tax cheats, and the country’s roughly 140 private banks can no longer rely on a reputation for secrecy to attract wealthy customers.

To try and compensate for the hundreds of billions of Swiss francs withdrawn in the wake of the tax probes, banks that once relied on word-of-mouth referral have brushed up their sales pitches and hit the road to attract new clients, particularly in Asia, the world’s fastest production line for multi-millionaires and billionaires.

“The key paradigm shift is that, in the old days, Swiss private banking imported clients,” said Zeno Staub, the chief executive of Swiss bank Vontobel. “Now we export services.”

To compete across borders, banks either need scale, or a specialist niche. Industry experts expect a gradual wave of takeovers and closures to shrink the sector, possibly by up to a third, once long-running US tax investigations involving dozens of banks conclude. Some are expected to be wrapped up in the next 12 months, but others could drag on.

The tectonic shifts expected in an industry steeped in hundreds of years of tradition prompted speculation last week of a tie-up between Credit Suisse, the country’s second-biggest bank, and Julius Baer, its third-largest listed wealth manager.

Analysts questioned the logic of such a takeover for Credit Suisse, which only recently agreed to pay $2.6bn to settle a tax probe with the United States, hollowing out its reserves for such a big deal.

Julius Baer is in the midst of its own US criminal investigation for aiding tax evasion, and a source familiar with the matter said the case for a deal between the two banks was weak for now and that any possible merger would be at least two to five years away.

But the speculation of such a tie-up underlines the sense of change afoot in the wood-panelled private banks of Geneva and Zurich, from which rich clients withdrew a net 350bn Swiss francs ($381bn) between 2008 and 2014, according to an estimate from accounting firm PricewaterhouseCoopers.

Profits have been eroded by the outflows and clients’ preference for low-risk holdings, which generate weaker returns for banks. The number of loss-making banks rose by almost 50 percent in 2013 to 34 compared to a year ago, according to a study by auditor KPMG that looked at 94 Swiss private banks.

The KPMG study, which excluded some big banks like UBS and Credit Suisse, also showed private banks’ return on equity - a key measure of profitability - fell by more than 75% between 2006 and 2013.

Boned-up bankers

Before the 2007-08 financial crisis and subsequent increase in regulatory vigilance, not much had fundamentally changed in the world of Switzerland’s often family-run private banks since the Napoleonic era. Customers came to Zurich and Geneva to park their money, and the bankers did not have to do much to keep it.

Once-a-year meetings with clients left plenty of time for long lunches and afternoon tipples.

Now, with the threat of hefty sanctions for tax evasion and customers anxious for returns in an era of record low interest rates, bankers have to bone up on investment trends and regulatory small print.