Fitch: Shariah-based banks continue to suffer from liquidity challenges

The Islamic banking sector in Bangladesh continued to face liquidity challenges, Fitch Rating said in its latest report released on Wednesday.

The report by the US credit rating agency, however, said that liquidity was improving amid notable public demand for Islamic deposit products.

Islamic banks held 25.3% of all domestic industry deposits at the end of the first half of 2023, albeit down from 28.2% at the end of the first half of 2022.

Islamic banks faced sizable customer deposit outflows in 2022 and in the first half of 2023 and lower liquidity buffers than conventional banks amid reports of loan irregularities.

Islamic banks' excess liquidity -- defined as total cash reserves minus required reserves with Bangladesh Bank -- declined significantly by 66.6% year-on-year (Tk982 crore) at the end of H1 of 2023.

However, excess liquidity has since improved with a 12.7% quarterly rise.

In contrast, deposit growth is slowing. Islamic banks' total deposits grew by only 3.8% year-on-year as of H1 of 2023; a significant fall from the 12% year-on-year growth of H1 of 2022.

Islamic banks' vulnerability to short-term liquidity challenges is demonstrated by the fall in the liquidity coverage ratio (LCR) to 87.7% at end-2022 (end-2021: 188.5%), below the regulatory requirement of 100%.

Conventional banks had adequate liquidity profiles, with an industry average LCR of 154%, the Fitch analysis said.

Bangladesh had the eighth-largest Islamic banking market globally at end-2022, with total assets of Tk4,970,700 crore ($45.3 billion), ahead of Indonesia, Bahrain, Pakistan, Egypt, Jordan and Oman, based on data from the Islamic Financial Services Board.

The market share, based on industry loans, is rising and reached 29.1% at end-1H23 (end-1H22: 28.5%).

Islamic banks in Bangladesh can receive customer deposits based on either mudaraba (a profit-and-loss sharing contract) or wadiah (a safe-keeping contract).

Fitch hasn't observed Islamic banks passing on losses or not paying profits to depositors. Passing losses can increase reputational risk and may lead to customer deposits outflows.

Fitch also expects that the central bank, Bangladesh Bank, would not let depositors bear losses as this would shake investor confidence in the banking system. Financing based on profit and loss (mudaraba and musharaka) was less than 1% of total financing.

Green financing accounted for 3.7% (Tk15,718 crore, or $1.4 billion) of all financing provided by Islamic banks at end-1H23.

The Islamic finance industry in Bangladesh continues to face key structural impediments.

These include a lack of sukuk and other sharia-compliant investment options, gaps in human capital development, a lack of unified Shariah rulings, and an Islamic finance regulatory framework that requires an update.

In general, the banking sector's balance sheets, governance and regulatory quality are weak. The central bank has taken steps to improve governance at public-sector banks, including the appointment of observers to bank boards, but progress has been slow.