The gateway to entering the digital banking (DB) system in Bangladesh is full of long complicated steps that may deter the average person from ever opening an account.
If a person wants to open an account, they cannot just take physical cash to the banks and convert it.
According to Bangladesh Bank's "Guidelines to Establish Digital Bank", digital banks are restricted from issuing any physical instruments for transactions, and also barred from providing any over the counter (OTC) service as well.
Therefore, to start a digital bank account, customers must deposit printed money through some other financial institution like a conventional bank, agent banking, mobile financial services (MFS) or etc first.
Meanwhile, commercial banks are quickly trying to join the bandwagon of getting a digital bank licence from Bangladesh Bank, despite having all the benefits of digital banks from being conventional banks.
Economists feel that conventional banks will not be able to add any additional value in managing digital banks.
And in this case, they think that mobile financial service (MFS) companies will benefit the most.
As per guidelines of Bangladesh Bank, any digital bank shall not provide any OTC service.
But the question remains how a digital bank gateway can be functional if a customer cannot transact his/her cash there.
Mezbaul Haque, spokesperson of Bangladesh Bank, told Dhaka Tribune: “A customer cannot deposit cash in a digital bank directly. They have to join a digital bank by depositing their money through a financial institution -- like a conventional bank, agent banking or MFS provider -- with whom the digital bank licence-holder has an agreement.”
“We have received 52 applications for digital banking. However, it has not yet been decided when the licence will be given. Actually we don't want to rush anything. We will complete the licencing process after proper verification.”
Giving an example, he further said: “Suppose a customer in Panchagarh registered his digital bank account through the app and then he got a KYC number. With that, he can deposit money in nominated financial institutions and convert his/her money digitally. Then it will be added to their digital bank account. Then they can continue transactions from anywhere in the world.”
Asked how many banks will be given licence for digital banking initially, the BB executive director said that the number was not yet decided upon.
Economists and bankers said that all digital banks provide, in general, low-cost products that are delivered faster than those offered by existing banks.
Ahsan H Mansur, executive director of the Policy Research Institute (PRI) told Dhaka Tribune: “Conventional banks will not be able to add any additional value in managing digital banks, but those who are not doing conventional banking will benefit the most.”
“MFS companies like bKash and Nagad will be ahead in this race, as they can easily convert their existing customers directly into digital banking. Moreover, they already have related infrastructure all over the country,” the former IMF economist further explained.
“The condition of the banking sector in the country is not so good. The central bank has failed to cope with the situation. People depositing money in banks or non-banking financial institutions are not getting their money back. At such a time, it has to be considered how timely it will be to give away digital bank licences. If the licence of these banks is given to anyone without proper verification, then the result may be disastrous,” he added.
Regarding difference between digital banking and conventional banking, Mashrur Arefin, managing director and CEO of City Bank, and vice-chairman of the Association of Bankers, Bangladesh (ABB) told the media that a conventional bank with its conventional mindset, its physical presence related to cost structure, its culture of necessary bureaucracy, its knack for financing large-size projects, etc -- can never turn into a digital bank.
“At most, what it can do is offer its full suite of retail banking, small and micro-finance and card products through people's phone sets.
“That's classic internet banking where a brick-and-mortar conventional bank basically creates a complementary channel for its product and service offerings to individual people, not so much to businesses. It is basically an extension of its conventionality by other means, that is by technological means,” Arefin added.
The central bank informed that after finalizing the guidelines to establish a digital bank on June 14 this year, Bangladesh Bank invited applications, which ended on August 17.
A total of 52 entities submitted their applications with a non-refundable deposit of Tk5 lakh each.
The banking regulator is yet to publish the complete list of applicants.
However, a minimum capital of Tk125 crore will be required to set up a digital bank, while Tk500 crore is required to open a conventional bank.
Bangladesh Bank in its guideline also said that a branchless end-to-end virtual banking system can give the banking system a mileage and momentum to reach the banking at the last mile of the country for creating employment opportunities, ensuring economic and financial stability of the economy as well as ensuring a sound financial ecosystem for the country.
The establishment of digital banks and it will be governed by the Bank Company Act, 1991 (as amended), Bangladesh Payment and Settlement Systems Regulations, 2014.