CPD responds to BGMEA on RMG minimum wage analysis

The Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD) has responded to observations raised by the Bangladesh Garment Manufacturers and Exporters Association (BGMEA) regarding CPD’s analysis on minimum wages in the readymade garment (RMG) sector.

In a letter, issued Sunday and addressed to BGMEA president Mahmud Hasan Khan, CPD executive director Dr Nazneen Ahmed thanked BGMEA for its November 19 letter following CPD’s November 18 media briefing.

Addressing household size and income earners, CPD clarified that it used medians—four family members and 1.58 earning members per household—drawn from existing published studies rather than conducting a new representative survey.

Using four members is below the HIES 2022 urban average of 4.18 and national average of 4.26, showing CPD did not intentionally inflate figures.

Substituting SEDS 2023’s 3.96 family size would shift the poverty-line wage estimate marginally from Tk18,578 to Tk18,392—a difference of Tk186—while keeping other assumptions unchanged.

Similarly, using HIES 2022’s urban average of 1.37 earners would yield a higher wage requirement per earner than CPD’s 1.58 median.

CPD noted that combining past studies, including its 2023 survey of 228 workers across 76 factories as well as larger studies by ACD and ILO-UN Women, does not substitute for a fresh, scientifically sampled survey, nor did CPD claim family sizes grew or earners fell between 2023 and 2026.

On poverty lines, CPD stated that the Dhaka Urban Upper Poverty Line from HIES 2022 applies to urban areas across Dhaka division, including industrial hubs like Gazipur and Narayanganj, where workers rent homes and buy essentials in the market.

Relying on rural poverty lines or taking a simple average of urban and rural lines without worker distribution data would be inappropriate, though a worker-weighted average using data from BGMEA and the Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics (BBS) would be welcome, rather than weighting by export volume.

CPD also rejected concerns of double-counting housing costs.

It explained that rent was deducted from BBS non-food expenditure and tobacco from food expenditure before calculating essential expenses—covering clothing, utilities, education, transport, personal care, and communication—consistent with the Anker living-wage methodology.

Regarding other points, CPD noted that raising the annual increment from 5% to 9% from December 1, 2024, helps existing workers and raises factory labor costs, but does not alter the Tk12,500 entry-level minimum wage for newly hired workers.

While focusing on entry-level wages as a baseline, CPD stressed the need for a proper grade-wise structure based on skills, responsibilities, experience, and productivity, alongside an indicative wage range balancing basic needs with industry capacity, production costs, interest rates, export prices, and US tariff pressures.

Outlining its stance, CPD urged wage decisions grounded in updated data and Section 141 of the Bangladesh Labour Act 2006.

While supporting wage increases, CPD opposed vandalism or unrest and governance issues like energy shortages, high interest rates, or corruption should not be shifted onto workers through low wages.