Interim govt’s term nearly over, but move to split NBR in limbo

The long-discussed initiative to split the National Board of Revenue (NBR) into two separate entities—Revenue Policy and Revenue Management—is effectively stalling during the tenure of the interim government.

Legal and procedural complexities, opposition from the administration cadre, internal protests within the NBR, punitive actions against officials, and the resulting negative impact on revenue collection have together pushed the proposed structural reform into deep uncertainty.

Despite the promulgation of an ordinance, the split could not be implemented due to the absence of necessary rules and procedural preparations.

Resistance from the administration cadre, disputes over secretary-level appointments, and legal notices have effectively frozen the process ahead of the national election.

According to government officials and economists, there is no longer sufficient time, preparation, or political consensus to complete such a major administrative reorganization before the election.

As a result, the plan to abolish the NBR and form two new divisions has, for now, come to a standstill.

Multiple sources say that opposition from a section of the administration cadre, legal challenges, and disagreements over secretary appointments in the run-up to the election have rendered the process virtually inoperative.

A new turn emerged on January 28, when a joint secretary of the Cabinet Division, Tanvir Ahmed, served legal notices to seven secretaries challenging the legality of dissolving the NBR and forming the Revenue Policy and Revenue Management divisions.

The notice demanded the cancellation or withdrawal of the ordinance, arguing that it effectively excluded administration cadre officers from secretary appointments, unlawfully harming their promotion prospects, service conditions, administrative structure, and future careers.

The notice warned of legal action if steps were not taken within three days.

Meanwhile, a group of senior administration cadre officials met the Finance Adviser, urging him to step back from appointing secretaries to the two new divisions before the election.

They argued that such a large-scale administrative overhaul on the eve of elections could create further complications. In this context, senior NBR sources say that appointments and related activities are unlikely to progress under the current government.

Background

The government had issued the “Revenue Policy and Revenue Management Ordinance, 2025” on May 12, 2025, to split the NBR.

The motive was that separating policy formulation from revenue collection and implementation would enhance efficiency, accountability, and transparency in tax administration.

However, the ordinance triggered strong backlash from tax, VAT, and customs cadre officials within the NBR, who alleged that it was issued without consultation, ignored internal stakeholders, and aimed to establish dominance of non-revenue cadres in policymaking positions.

Protests and work stoppages followed at NBR headquarters and tax and customs offices nationwide.

As a result, tax offices, VAT commissionerates, and customs houses were partially or fully closed for several days, directly affecting revenue collection.

The tax-to-GDP ratio fell to 6.6% in the current fiscal year, down from 7.4% the previous year, dealing a significant blow to the government.

The government responded with a hardline stance. Four senior tax, VAT, and customs officials—known for their integrity—were sent into compulsory retirement, including one commissioner.

Around 35 officials were dismissed or temporarily suspended for alleged involvement in the movement, and several were placed under investigation by the Anti-Corruption Commission, intensifying fear and resentment within the administration.

To defuse tensions, the government formed a five-member advisory committee and later amended and reissued the ordinance in September 2025.

The amendment promised dominance of revenue cadres in the Revenue Management Division and inclusion of experts in economics, commerce, and tax policy in the Policy Division. Still, a large section of the NBR believes the core structural problems remain unresolved.

Legal experts later argued that the ordinance conflicts with Article 55(6) of the Constitution, that departments cannot retain implementation authority under the Rules of Business, 1996, and that without amending multiple regulations—including the Cadre Composition Rules, 1980—the split cannot be enforced. Consequently, the process became entangled in legal complexities.

Although the National Implementation Committee (NIKAR) recently gave policy-level approval to draft amendments to the Rules of Business and Allocation of Business, final clearance from the Secretaries Committee on Administrative Development remains pending. Repeated cancellation of meetings has made it clear that completing the split within the interim government’s tenure will be difficult.

Meanwhile, the government has begun reconsidering and reducing penalties for some officials involved in the protests.

An Internal Resources Division notification reinstated additional tax commissioner Sehela Siddika, though her promotion was frozen for a year and her pay grade reduced by two levels. Similar relief is being processed for about 25 officials. However, no reconsideration has been offered to the five senior officials forced into compulsory retirement.

Transparency International Bangladesh Executive Director Dr Iftekharuzzaman said the turmoil surrounding the NBR split is unprecedented in global revenue administrations.

He criticized the ad hoc approach, undertaken without due process or involvement of core revenue collectors. While supporting the idea of separating revenue policy from administration, he stressed that the policy division must be an independent structure free from bureaucratic control and argued that the issue should be left to the next elected government.

Former NBR chairman Abdul Mazid believes the current structure is largely functional and that minor inconsistencies can be corrected later, while economist Dr Masrur Riaz also said it would be prudent to leave the decision to an elected government.

Despite these developments, Finance Adviser Dr Salehuddin Ahmed has expressed optimism that the process could be completed by February 12.

Speaking to reporters on January 7 after a meeting of the government procurement advisory committee, he said that most formalities were nearly complete and that the reform would be implemented during the interim government’s tenure, even if deadlines slipped.

However, an NBR member, speaking on condition of anonymity, told Dhaka Tribune that implementing such a major administrative reform without the cooperation of the administration cadre is extremely difficult, and their reluctance has significantly reduced the prospects.