Factory closures in Bangladesh is an obstacle to economic recovery

Protests by retrenched garment workers and job seekers continued in Ashulia and Gazipur, as workers from several garment factories and unemployed young adults demanded various concessions, prompting authorities to close over 60 factories on Wednesday.

Later, the law enforcement agencies intervened and managed to restore normalcy.

“The government will take immediate action to address the growing labor unrest, which officials believe is being fuelled by external influences,” said Asif Mahmud Shojib Bhuiyan, Labor and Employment adviser, following a meeting at the Ministry of Home Affairs on the day.

“We’ve had multiple discussions with both the workers and factory owners regarding the unrest,” said Asif Mahmud. “Our industry adviser has also been involved in these discussions. What we’ve learned from labor leaders is that the current protests lack a clear set of demands, leaving even the leaders puzzled. This suggests a significant involvement of external elements.”

Despite joint operations by the army and police, about 60-70 readymade garment (RMG) factories were forced to close on Tuesday due to worker protests fueled by these outsiders. The situation was calm in the industrial zones of Savar, Ashulia, and Gazipur in the morning, but protests reignited by noon, leading factory authorities to declare a holiday.

Workers have seen their slice of the global income pie shrink significantly over the past two decades, swelling inequality and depriving the combined labour force of trillions, the UN said Wednesday, reports AFP.

The United Nations' International Labour Organization said that the global labour income share -- or the proportion of total income in an economy earned by working -- had fallen by 1.6 percentage points since 2004.

"While the decrease appears modest in terms of percentage points, in 2024 it represents an annual shortfall in labour income of $2.4 trillion compared to what workers would have earned had the labour income share remained stable since 2004," the ILO said in a report.

The study highlighted the Covid-19 pandemic as a key driver of the decline, with almost half of the reduction in labour income share taking place during the pandemic years of 2020-2022.

The global crisis exacerbated existing inequalities, particularly as capital income has continued to concentrate ever more among the wealthiest, it said.

"Countries must take action to counter the risk of declining labour income share," Celeste Drake, the ILO deputy director-general, said in a statement.

"We need policies that promote an equitable distribution of economic benefits, including freedom of association, collective bargaining and effective labour administration, to achieve inclusive growth, and build a path to sustainable development for all."

Deepening inequality

The previous Awami Legue-led government in November last year had proposed a draft for RMG workers with Tk12,500 as the minimum monthly salary, raising it from Tk8,000, which had been objected by trade unions and other workers’ rights groups.

Since the beginning of last year, workers have been demanding Tk23,000 as the monthly minimum wage considering high inflation in the country, but their representative proposed Tk20,390 as the minimum wage.

In the draft proposal, the government proposed Tk12,500 gross wages with Tk6,700 basic salary for assistant operator under grade-5, followed by Tk13,025 gross with Tk 7,050 for general operator under grade-4, Tk13,550 gross salary with Tk7,400 for junior operator under grade-3, Tk14,150 gross salary with Tk7,800 basic wage for operator and Tk14,750 gross with Tk8,200 basic for senior operators.

In a report released in March earlier this year by the Fair Labor Association (FLA), they said buyers must commit to ensuring that costing and purchase orders accommodate the new minimum wage standards of TK12,500 and TK12,800 in Export Processing Zones (EPZs). 

Shockingly, the report reveals that over this period, there has been a meagre 0.95% increase in the monthly average net wage. In contrast, the inflation rate in Bangladesh soared by 9.02% in just the last year, leading to a 4.6% decline in the monthly average wage for workers.

Comparing these figures with the 2022 Global Living Wage Coalition (GLWC) estimate for Dhaka (TK23,254, or $211.90), the report highlights a significant living wage gap for Bangladeshi workers, amounting to TK12,040 ($109.70). This discrepancy underscores that the average monthly net wage in 2022 was 51.78% below the living wage benchmark.

The ILO stressed that technological advances, including automation, were a key driver of the declines in labour income share.

"While these innovations have boosted productivity and output, the evidence suggests that workers are not sharing equitably from the resulting gains," the UN labour agency said.

It voiced particular concern that the artificial intelligence boom risked deepening inequality further.

"If historical patterns were to persist... the recent breakthroughs in generative AI could exert further downward pressure on the labour income share," the report said, stressing "the importance of ensuring that any benefits of AI are widely distributed".

The ILO found that workers currently rake in just 52.3% of global income, while capital income -- earned by owners of assets like land, machines, buildings and patents -- accounts for the rest.

Since capital income tends to be concentrated among wealthier individuals, the labour income share is widely used as a measure of inequality.

It also helps measure progress towards the UN sustainable development goal aimed at significantly reducing inequality between and within countries between 2015 and 2030.

"The report indicates slow progress as the 2030 deadline approaches," ILO said.

The report also emphasized the stubbornly high incidence of young people who are not in employment, education or training (Neet).

Since 2015, the global percentage has slipped slightly, from 21.3% to 20.4% this year.

But there are major regional differences, with a third of youth in Arab states and nearly a quarter in Africa falling into the NEET category. 

The report also highlighted a large gender gap, with the global Neet incidence among young women standing at 28.2% -- more than double the 13.1% seen among young men.