Rising domestic debt puts China in a bind over canceling developing countries’ debts

China, which has lent nearly $1 trillion to around 150 developing countries, is now grappling with its own domestic “debt bomb,” leading Beijing to be reluctant to cancel large debts owed by struggling nations, as highlighted by Keith Bradsher in The New York Times. The country faces an alarming accumulation of debt at home, with trillions of dollars owed by local governments, off-the-books financial affiliates, and real estate developers. During US Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen's visit to China, one of the key issues was whether she could convince China to cooperate in addressing the evolving debt crisis faced by lower-income countries. However, China's state-controlled banking system is hesitant to accept losses on foreign loans when it already faces greater losses on loans within its borders.

 According to JPMorgan Chase researchers, China's overall debt, including households, companies, and the government, has reached 282% of its annual economic output, surpassing the average debt levels in developed economies worldwide. The rapid accumulation of debt relative to its economy sets China apart from most other countries and poses challenges in managing this debt burden. Although China's lending to developing countries represents a small proportion of its domestic debt (less than 6% of annual economic output), these loans are politically sensitive. Criticisms have emerged on Chinese social media, suggesting that the money should have been lent to support impoverished households and regions within China rather than abroad. Accepting significant losses on these loans would be unpopular within China.

 China's debt issues can be traced back to the real estate sector, which has experienced overbuilding, falling prices, and struggling buyers. In recent years, numerous real estate developers that borrowed money from overseas investors have defaulted on their debts. Developers also face challenges in repaying substantial debts to banks within China. Adding to the problem is the borrowing undertaken by local governments, which set up lightly regulated financing units over the past decade. These units borrowed heavily to cover daily expenses, including interest payments on other loans and infrastructure construction.

The overlap between real estate and government debt exacerbates the situation. Localities heavily relied on revenue from long-term leases for state land sold to developers. However, this revenue declined as private-sector developers ran out of funds to bid for land. Local financing affiliates borrowed heavily to purchase land at steep prices. Many financing affiliates face difficulties as the real estate market weakens.

 Fitch Ratings estimates that local governments in China have debts equivalent to 30% of the country's annual economic output. Their affiliated financing units owe an additional 40% to 50% of national work, although there may be some double counting as debt is shifted between local governments and their financing units. Excessive borrowing has left many local governments and their financing units unable to meet interest payments on their debts, resulting in a lack of funds for public services, healthcare, and pensions.

The debt troubles faced by China have also made it challenging for the country's banks to accept losses on loans to lower-income countries. Meanwhile, countries like Sri Lanka, Pakistan, and Suriname, heavily indebted to China, confront significant economic difficulties. The dependence of nearly two-thirds of developing economies on commodity exports adds further strain, with the World Bank predicting a 21% decline in commodity prices compared to the previous year.

China is the largest sovereign lender to developing countries, but Western hedge funds have also invested in bonds from these nations. However, China's lending tends to involve adjustable interest rates linked to rates in the West, while the bonds purchased by Western entities generally have fixed interest rates. As the Federal Reserve raised rates since March 2022, developing countries faced soaring debt payments to China.

If little is done to alleviate their debt burdens, the world's poorest governments will continue to allocate significant resources to debt repayment, hindering investments in essential public services. The impact will be felt by ordinary people in developing countries, who will be denied access to basic services due to their governments' unsustainable debts, as emphasized by Bradley Parks, the executive director of AidData.

Addressing China's domestic debt overhang requires long-term solutions. The country must gradually shift away from debt-fueled government construction projects and heavy national security spending, focusing more on consumer spending and services. However, powerful interests in Beijing and Chinese provincial capitals currently protect the existing economic priorities. While Janet Yellen aims to gather insights into China's financial plans, her ability to influence these plans is limited.

China's domestic debt challenges extend beyond quick fixes, and almost every province faces similar issues with troubled local financing units. Resolving the debt problem faced by developing countries poses a difficult task. Yellen's capacity to persuade China to accept debt write-downs is constrained, given the limited leverage the US and Yellen possess, according to Mark Sobel, a former longtime United States Treasury official cited by The New York Times.