Despite improvements in some of the microeconomic indicators, the overall macroeconomic sectors are lagging far behind the government's target for the current fiscal year, experts and economists said at a press briefing on Thursday.
They said this while publishing the "State of the Bangladesh Economy in FY2021-22" report, researched by the Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD) and the Independent Review of Bangladesh Development (IRBD) team.
So far, in FY22, citizens have suffered the most from inflation, the experts added.
At the same time, the prices of various commodities are rising in the international market and the prices of imported goods are rising due to the devaluation of the taka against the dollar, thus raising the trade deficit.
On the other hand, although revenue collection has increased from last year, it is still lagging far behind the government's target.
To meet this deficit, the National Board of Revenue (NBR) will have to increase revenue collection by 30.7%.
At the same time, the government's revenue from the sales of savings certificates has decreased by 26.3%, meaning the source of the internal debt is shrinking for the government. This is resulting in unsustainable recovery from Covid-19.
Fahmida Khatun, executive director of CPD, said: “The graph of improvement this year is much clearer than last year. However, it has not yet reached the stage of pre-Covid-19 years. So, it seems that the budget implementation will be challenging for the government.”
She further said that over the past several months, Bangladesh's macroeconomic management has experienced a testing time in the face of the Covid-19 pandemic.
The negative impact of the pandemic was manifested in the majority of the key macroeconomic indicators.
“In a good sign, however, in the early months of FY22, several indicators have shown signs of recovery. However, macroeconomic management is expected to remain no less challenging. The policymakers will need to duel with the fact that the economy will call for continued support for the desired recovery at a time when macroeconomic stability is under pressure. The present section reviews the trends of major macroeconomic variables to highlight the nature of recovery and the underlying challenges,” she added.
To clarify the revenue situation, she said that according to data available from NBR, during the July-October period of FY22, revenue mobilized by the NBR rose by 16.6% compared to the corresponding period of FY21.
“However, this growth is much lower than the annual target set by the national budget. In order to attain the annual growth target of 27.0%, NBR revenue will have to increase at a rate of 30.7% for the remainder of the fiscal year – which is a highly daunting task, to say the least,” Khatun stated.
According to the report, during the first quarter of FY22, the budget deficit — to the tune of Tk27,571 crore — remained lower than the Tk31,999 crore in the same period of FY21.
On a positive note, thanks to foreign aid inflow for Covid-19 financing, including for the purchase of vaccines, about 46.7% of the budget deficit was financed by net foreign financing despite the below-par performance of project aid in ADP financing, the report reads.
During the same period of FY21, only 29% of the budget deficit was financed by net foreign borrowing.
In response to a question about fiscal space and inflation, Mustafizur Rahman, distinguished fellow of CPD, said: “Although during the Covid-19 period a lot of FDI came from different countries and organizations, those came for very specific projects. So even if it wanted to, the government could not spend it directly on the stimulus package.”
On the other hand, the government is not able to help the new poor in that way; even though the government gives Tk2,500 to few families, according to their calculations, a family of four needs a minimum of Tk7,297 per month, Rahman said.
“The rising prices of essential commodities have caused serious anxiety, undermining the adjustment and recovery efforts. Increased prices in the international market, the falling value of BDT against major currencies of importing sources, and lack of good governance contributed to rising prices of essentials,” he further said.
“During the first quarter of FY22, the net sale of saving certificates was 26.3% lower. This would also mean that if there is any future rise of government borrowing, it is more likely to be serviced by higher bank borrowing by the government, which remains within the limit. All in all, the government's fiscal space is shrinking,” he added.
Khondaker Golam Moazzem, research director of CPD, said that in the last six months, they have seen the failure to control inflation, the sadden decision of diesel price hike, the lack of proper implementation of stimulus packages, the inability to make timely decisions by analyzing data, and the lack of control over large business groups.
“As a result, the recovery process from Covid-19 is not being sustainable,” he added.
Towfiqul Islam Khan, senior research fellow of the CPD, said that due to a lack of accurate data, it is becoming difficult to make accurate calculations in many cases.
“However, for the implementation of the budget, the government should make new plans by analyzing the data for the rest of the year,” he said.