Budget FY24: Social Security Net allocation not helping the poor

The government should reduce spending to reduce the fiscal deficit in FY24, according to the Policy Research Institute of Bangladesh (PRI). The think tank also believes that the majority of the Social Safety Net (SSN) allocation proposed will not benefit the poor.

Executive Director of PRI, Ahsan H Mansur said: “The government should adjust the budget expenses by cutting the allocation under the Annual Development Programme (ADP) and bringing down operating costs in order to contain inflation.”

Mansur also stated during a post-budget discussion on Tuesday that pension and savings certificates should not be included in the Social Safety Net (SSN). 

The current allocation in the social safety net should be raised to safeguard low-income people, as inflation in the country has risen by roughly 10% and is expected to rise higher in the coming days.

Abdur Razzaque, PRI research director, delivered the keynote address during the occasion. 

In his presentation, he demonstrated that approximately 52% of social safety net allocation will be spent on pensions and gratuities, SMEs and agriculture subsidies, and saving certificate interest, none of which will benefit the poorer segment of the population.

Allocation for pay and allowance exceeds Tk1 lakh crore in FY23, but in FY24, the government proposed increasing the allocation to Tk126,300 crore, which is 2.52% of GDP, including the pension scheme. 

But according to the presentation, in FY24, more than Tk3 lakh crore in total would go into debt interest payments, subsidies, and government officials' salaries and allowances.

Razzaque said: “In absolute terms, the allocation for pay and allowances in the budget has grown substantially since FY11. There is further pressure for a general salary increase for public sector employees before the next general elections.”

It's also stated that subsidy allocation increased by eight times in the last 12 years.

Despite the IMF condition to reduce subsidy allocation in different sectors, the government has increased the subsidy allocation by 14.5% to Tk84 thousand crore for the next fiscal year 

In FY22, the subsidy allocation was Tk42 thousand crore, which is going to be doubled in FY24.

The allocation has increased by almost four times, since FY11. 

Razzaque also said that the growth and investment target in the new budget for FY24 is unrealistic, as the country's economy is under pressure. 

The government did not take proper steps to tackle the inflation. If proper policy measures are not taken, this situation may worsen. The government has to pay around $940 billion in loan interest in the next year. So, the country's economy could face more pressure, he added. 

Mansur said that the country is currently facing crises centring on three issues: monetary policy, revenue policy and foreign loans.

He continued saying: “Many countries across the globe have increased loan interest rates to curb high inflation. Interest rates are usually fixed considering the global economic situation, but the rate is fixed in Bangladesh. This is not the right decision.”

The government borrowed a high amount of money last year from banks, which is the highest in Bangladesh's 50 years of history. The government took a chance by keeping a low-interest rate.

“If the government borrows a large amount of money from the banking system, the inflow of funds to the private sector will be squeezed and it will affect the investment in the private sector.”

The former IMF official said that if the government prints the taka to maintain the expenses proposed in the budget for the upcoming fiscal year, inflation will climb further. So, the government should think of taking some fiscal measures, reducing ADP allocation, and avoiding borrowing a large amount of money from the banking sector.