CPD: Govt loses 6,000C in wealth tax annually

Bangladesh loses Tk6,000 crore in wealth tax each year, according to a report conducted by the research institute Center for Policy Dialogue (CPD).

The actual market price of land per katha is greater than the mouza rate set by the government for each of Dhaka's chosen neighbourhoods.

According to the think tank, the valuation foundation should be adjusted, and the disparity between the value of the property purchased 30 years ago and property purchased recently should be reconciled through adjustment with current market pricing.

CPD's Dialogue on the "State and Scope of Property Taxation in Bangladesh" was speaking on the matter on Wednesday.

The keynote speech was given by Debapriya Bhattacharya, a distinguished fellow of the research organization. 

In his presentation, he said that the wealth tax has not increased at the same rate as Bangladesh's economy over the past ten years. Wealth tax is anticipated to rise by 0.4% for every 1% increase in GDP. 

As a result, Bangladesh loses Tk6,000 crores in wealth tax annually.

The presentation stated that revenue collection in Bangladesh is largely dependent on indirect taxes (particularly VAT).

This imposes a burden on marginalized people through double taxation, deviates from tax justice, and leads to rising income inequality. 

More than 55% of indirect tax revenue comes from domestic sources (e.g., VAT). 

Indirect tax revenue from trade-dependent consumption sources will diminish due to the expected trade loss from LDC graduation. 

The share of direct tax is stagnant at around 33% for the last five fiscal years.

Currently, there is no specific tax referred to as a wealth tax in the country, however, there are six types of taxes and duties that can be roughly categorized as wealth-related. 

These include the land development tax, holding tax, capital gains tax, stamp duty, wealth surcharge, and, to a lesser extent, the gift tax, although its effectiveness is limited.

Property tax obtained from land tax and stamp duty has been constantly declining for the last five years and has been only about 5% of total direct tax during this timeframe. 

Strengthening collection from property taxes should be a critical part of the ongoing domestic revenue mobilization effort. Need to explore new sources of direct tax, such as inheritance tax.

Inheritance tax, a form of wealth tax, is levied on property and money acquired by gift or inheritance.

Debapriya emphasized on the growing wealth and income inequality within the country and highlighted the need to enhance tax fairness by increasing tax collection.

He said that Bangladesh's wealth tax situation is comparable to Africa. African countries have a wealth tax of 0.3% of GDP. 

In Bangladesh, this rate is 0.27% and as a result, there is a significant rise in social inequality.

Speaking at the event, Ahsan H Mansur, executive director of the Policy Research Institute (PRI), said that inheriting wealth without paying any taxes worsens wealth disparity. It should include taxes."

To remedy this issue, he pushed for the imposition of inheritance taxes.

The think tank argues that the valuation basis should be adjusted and that the disparity between the value of the property purchased 30 years ago and property purchased recently should be fixed through an adjustment with current market pricing.

According to the presentation, the mouza rate is just 29% of the actual market price of land in Dhaka's designated neighbourhoods. Traditional areas benefit from tax breaks that new residential areas do not. For example, in certain areas of Mohammadpur like Bosila and Katashur (Inside the Beri Bhad) where mouzas per katha rate is Tk1.88 million but the actual or market price of the land in April 2023 was Tk3.3 million. 

That means the mouza rate is 57% lower than the market price.

In Faydabad, Uttara its 54%; Uzampur, Uttar Khan 45%; Faydabad, Uttara 35%; Dhanmondi, Road 15, 33%; Hazaribag, Dhaka 21%; Jigatola, Hazaribag, Dhaka 7%; Lalmatia, Dhaka 6% and in Dhanmondi, Road 31 actual market price is 5% higher than government-determined mouza rate.  

CPDs recommendations

The think tank strongly recommended the inheritance tax be implemented in place of the present gift tax.

A tax may be levied at the moment of ownership transfer and issue of a succession certificate.

According to the presentation, Bangladesh already has a property tax system in place, but it is underperforming in terms of justice, efficiency, and transparency- there is a need for reform.

It called for addressing numerous barriers and possibilities and suggested remedial intervention or a Strategic Implementation Plan for improving existing property tax collection in Bangladesh. It also suggested Implementing a new property tax system, such as an inheritance tax, to generate new direct tax revenue.

Inter-linkages among the property taxes, tools of the property tax system, sectors, agencies and recommendations to be realized also should be looked at.

CPD stressed the need to ensure that the valuations are based on market values for land development (e.g. land buying/selling price), holding tax (e.g. return/income from the asset), wealth surcharge (e.g. the current market price of assets), capital gains and stamp duty.

Furthermore, it recommended gradually rationalizing tax rates, including various tax rates on land/house/apartment registration that are combinedly found to be a high burden that discourages citizens from disclosing the market value.

Additionally, a comprehensive data system needs to be developed which should include NID, TIN, BIN, BO account, bank account and asset register (including land, hold and capital market). 

NID should provide the reference point to merge all these different sources of information.

Finally, CPD called for strengthening the tax administration – not only NBR but also other agencies, including the Local Government and Land Ministry, with a view to improving professional capacity. 

Ahead of the upcoming elections, the CDP says, one of the ways to put forward such a reform agenda is during the run-up to a national election through election manifestos of the political parties in a democratic setting– 2023 may be an opportune time.

Land Minister Saifuzzaman Chowdhury has expressed hope that, starting next year, it will be possible to deposit approximately Tk 2000 crore as revenue in the government treasury through land development tax. This amount represents an increase of almost three times or more than 200 percent compared to the previous collection from land tax prior to the implementation of the digital land development tax system.