A large portion of the money from the Government Social Safety Net Programs (SSNP), particularly for the elderly and widow's allowance, ends up in the wrong hands, according to a survey report issued by the Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD).
If those ineligible claimants can be identified, another 2.5 million elders and widows can benefit from the Tk1,500 crore.
It is estimated that 3.3 million elderly people and 2.5 million widows are still eligible for benefits but are not receiving them.
Beneficiaries must pay a Tk2653 bribe in order to get old-age benefits. The total ranges from Tk5,00 to Tk6,000.
CPD discussed their findings at “How to improve coverage and effectiveness of the Social Safety Net Programmes? Findings from a primary survey.”
The keynote presentation was delivered by Khondaker Golam Moazzem, research director at CPD.
This study assesses the selection process, administrative efficiency, allowance, estimation of demand, required resource estimation, and demand and supply issues from beneficiaries as well as government officials," he said.
The elderly and widow programs are overburdened with ineligible beneficiaries, necessitating additional coverage and having less access to these services and receiving minimal support.
It is necessary to estimate the gaps in social safety net programs (SSNP) across several categories. Most essential, this assessment is required to calculate the necessary amount of resources and to discover potential alternate sources in both the public and private sectors, he explained.
The report stated that the SSNP allocations account for Tk1,135.8 billion, 16.75% of the national budget and 2.55% of GDP in FY2023.
In FY2023, social safety net-related activities cover a total of 118 different programs under nine categories.
However, if the programs are evaluated using the internationally accepted definition of social safety net programs, the share will fall. Some programs, such as pensions for retired government employees and interest payments on savings certificates, will be excluded.
To eliminate hunger and poverty in the country, pension, widow allowance, and main stipend were implemented. These three programs were chosen with the life cycle approach in mind and due to the flawed selection process, a number of eligible widows and elderly people are being excluded from this support program.
According to the study, there is an issue with selecting a beneficiary. Non-eligible beneficiaries (elderly and widows) receive roughly Tk1,500 crore every year as a result of a low beneficiary target and administrative flaws.
According to the report, around 45% of beneficiaries receive an allowance despite owning more than five decimals of land. Non-beneficiaries, on the other hand, have land with less than five decimals and an income of less than Tk1,000.
Approximately 95% of the elderly and 97% of widow non-beneficiaries receive no other allowance, pension, or VGD benefits.
However, approximately 2% of beneficiaries also have VGD cards, and approximately 6% of existing beneficiaries receive multiple benefits.
The report also stated that around 30% of old-age beneficiaries believe they are not eligible for any safety net benefits.
Around 33% of widow beneficiaries believe that they are not eligible to receive any safety net benefits
According to the Old Age Allowance (OAA) report, 63% of older beneficiaries have mobile banking accounts; however, not all beneficiaries use their mobile banking services to transact money. 37% of beneficiaries do not have a mobile banking account and must rely on family members to withdraw funds, which has additional negative consequences. However, with the current allowance amount, a beneficiary is unable to purchase the commodities they require each month.
As discovered, widows are less likely to be involved in various economic activities, and their average earning is higher than that of senior beneficiaries, which is Tk1,294.
On average, old age recipients receive roughly Tk1,500 every three months. The allocation amount is comparable to that of the old-age beneficiaries.
The study suggested that the allowance amount has been proposed to be increased to Tk2,500 for old age and widows and Tk2,000 for others. Given that a total of Tk27,958 crore will be required to cover the qualified but uninsured. The total sum required will be Tk88,824 crore. This sum of money could be financed from Bangladesh's yearly tax loss.
The program's principal guest, Rashed Khan Menon, president of the Parliamentary Standing Committee on the Ministry of Social Welfare, stated that social security should be regarded as a right.
He claimed that the state was politically and economically imprisoned by a tiny group of wealthy individuals and that while poverty was declining, inequality was rising.
In order to minimize inequality, social security programs should be expanded. However, the social security sector lacks the resources to increase allocations, which can only be accomplished if tax evasion is stopped.
He proposed boosting the Social Services Department's manpower.
Aroma Dutta, MP, member of the standing committee on Ministry of Social Welfare, Bangladesh Parliament in her speech said: “Not only the government but NGOs also have to take responsibility for the social safety net programs. Because in the context of our country, it is very difficult for the government to carry forward such a huge responsibility. NGOs can play a major role in creating social awareness of SSNP.”
“Moreover, NGOs can distribute a part of the income to these sectors instead of just calculating the profit from microcredit disbursements. Why are they not doing it, I want to question their conscience,” she added.
Rasheda K Choudhury, former advisor to the caretaker government and executive director of CAMPE and Fahmida Khatun, executive director of CPD also spoke at the events.
A total of 486 people were surveyed. Old age: 108, widow: 200, primary student guardians: 178. The sample size was calculated using 29 upazila divided into 15 districts and 8 divisions. The sample locations were chosen with high poverty rates and low SSNP intervention in mind.